Carly Patterson or Nastia Liukin? Which one do you prefer?

Question

Carly Patterson: 2004 Athens Olympic All-Around Gold Medalist

Nastia Liukin: 2008 Beijing Olympic All-Around Gold Medalist

Which one do you prefer?

Also, if Carly Patterson didn't retire and decided to compete in the 2008 Beijing All-Around Competition, do you think she would've clinched the gold medal or do you think Nastia Liukin would still be the gold medalist?

Answer 1

Liukin all the way! She's amazing!

Answer 2

I like Nastia, she's so  graceful

Answer 3

carly patterson!! :D

Answer 4

i like shawn johnson the best but out of those two nastia  

Answer 5

nastia... she ruled with more grace and execution... plus she's pretty much the most gorgeous girl i've ever seen

Answer 6

they are both champions!

Answer 7

Nastia Liukin has great form and grace. Carly Patterson just did the tricks well, no real artistry to the routines, just like Shawn Johnson. Nastia had great flow AND she also did the tricks well. The judges like it if gymnasts are graceful and artistic. There are two kinds of gymnastics, artistic and rythmic. Artistic is the kind that most people know as "real gymnastics", and the type that Nastia and Carly and everyone competed in. Rythmic gymnastics is where you have ribbons and you twirl them, and you have hula hoops the you do flips through. So, what I say is, if the type of gymnastics I do is called "artistic", why not put some artistry into it? That is exactly what Nastia does. She is my all-time favorite gymnast, and her figure is just beautiful. She has long legs, long torso, and a skinny figure, while most other gymnasts have short legs, a short torso, and a very muscular figure. She also has great b*****s, while most of the Chinese are flat chested. So, yes, I would say that Nastia is who I prefer.

Answer 8

Shawn =P

Lol, Nastia.

Answer 9

I say Nastia. Shes an amazing gymnast and does every routine with such grace.