Carolina skiff jv 17 or boston whaler montauk 15?

Question

hello i am a 15 year old and my dad recently bought both of these boats. i am very experienced with boats and outboards alike. he said i could pick one of the 2 boats for myself here the the pros and cons of each boat

Carolina skiff-

pros- bigger, has bimini.

cons- more gas, slow, more maintence, needs engine work.

Boston whaler-

pros- has stereo, depth/fishfinder, accessories, bigger engine, less maintence.

Cons- smaller, no bimini.

im going to be using the boat mainly for fishing and going to the nearby island

which one is better/which one should i keep

Answer 1

The whaler looks like it would be YOUR best choice.  

The Carolina Skiff maybe a more stable fishing platform, but if the engine is questionable that would not be good to have it break down and not be able to motor home.  

Just be safe and - Have Fun!

Answer 2

Go with the whaler better boat alround.

Answer 3

Boston Whaler, we own a 27 foot outrage and previously had a 18 foot outrage.  They are tough boats, hold their value better than most boats, and the peace of mind that goes with a totally unsinkable boat!

Answer 4

boston whaler. if your fishing the bimini will only get in the way. 2 ft isnt to much of a loss. plus the boston got more acc.

Answer 5

I  think you'd like the Whaler better in the long run.   I like the skiff but I note "engine work' that could mean $$$$ now.  Don't forget to "THANK DAD" !!!!!!