Carrie Underwood vs. Jessica Simpson?

Question

hi everyone i just wanted to do this survey, who do you think is better overall? looks, personality, voice and why? and if you think carrie is better do you think tony romo was stupid to break up with her?

Answer 1

Carrie Underwood is better.  She is definitely the better singer.  It is really hard to win American Idol you have to be really good.  I think she is prettier too.  We don't really know about their real personalities so tony just may prefer Jessica's.

Answer 2

carrie underwood

Answer 3

Wow what kind of question is that?

Carrie underwood!!

Jessica is pretty

But carrie has the looks and the voice to match and Idk what happen between them so i can't judge

Answer 4

CarrieUndwerwood, Jessica never had much success.

Carries had tons.

Answer 5

i think that carrie underwood is probably better overall  i think that jessica  is prettier by a little but she is kinda S****y and clings to  whoever shes dating  plus her music is kinda odd  like public affair the music video was so  "im in love with myself"  and carrie is really into her music and not herself.  

Answer 6

Go Jessica!! Carrie Underwood is a hoebag andPamela needs to eat some meat!

Answer 7

I think Carrie Underwood. She's more down to earth, and seems like an amazing girl to be around. When Jessica Simpson on the other hand, she's a good girl but sometimes it seems as though she plays stupid and women have been through alot in the past for her to just throw it away like that.

Answer 8

Carrie Underwood for all four categories. I cannot stand how Jessica Simpson sings.

Answer 9

Carrie Underwood comes across very genuine and down to earth in every way. I have heard from a friend in L.A. that Jessica Simpson is very "Hollywood". It's been said that her fame has gotten to her head. Tony Romo seems kinda s****.. So, he should probably stick w/ Jessica. I'm stricktly going by how they come across in interviews and TV. I don't know anyone of them.  

Answer 10

Carrie Underwood... she's actually one of the only country singers I can listen to on a regular basis.

Answer 11

Carrie Underwood!

Sounds Better, Classy, Beautiful

Answer 12

i think carrie underwood her voice is much stronger and bigger. her personality is a little brighter too

Answer 13

carrie underwood without a doubt. jessica simpson is a stupid s**t at least carrie has a good head on her shoulder. don't get me wrong Jessica can sing but carries voice is much purer. and carrie underwood has some realness to her cause she came from nothing and won a competition to get famous jessica had her daddy do all the work, and tony was retarded for breaking up with her. but u never know what happened , u don't know what happened behind closed doors, you can believe everything you read. there could have been more to the story that tabloids left out.

:]

Answer 14

Carrie underwood

Jessica simpson has a better voice but carrie is prettier and has a better personality.

I can't say tony romo is stupid because i dont know why they broke up.

Answer 15

Carrie Underwood is way better then Jessica. She's 100% real, no fake b***s or botox. Also, she has a much better personality and voice. Anybody is stupid to break up with her, but hey if things don't work out then there's no point in staying together.

Answer 16

Carrie underwood is more talented

but i like Jessica Simpson more...

Answer 17

Carrie Underwood. She's way more successful.

Answer 18

I cant make my mind up on this one... I dont care for either but they both do have good trats overall...

I personally think Jessica is more attractive than Carrie

I have seen both celebs doing interviews on the TV and stuff and looking at Carrie Underwoods first audition on American Idol, I would say Carrie had the better personality.

Carrie also has the best voice... even ashlee simpson has a better voice than Jessica and that's saying something surely!

I'm not sure weather he was wrong or not to break up with her, you never know what goes on behined closed doors do ya?

Urmmmmm I would say CARRIE is better overall

Answer 19

Carrie Underwood. shes pretty and talented.

Jessica simpson... isn't really much of either... she has an OK voice... Carrie has an EXCELLENT voice.

so overall... CARRiE UNDERWOOD :D

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?...

Answer 20

looks - jessica

voice - carrie cause her voice soundsss way betterrr

personality- carrie cause shes not dumb like jessica

and the last one idk

Answer 21

I think Carrie Underwood would win, because she's got a "cleaner reacord than Jessica Simpson, but I don't like her much, so no, I don't think Tony Romo was stupid to break up with her.

Answer 22

I can't judge Tony Romo because I don't know the circumstances. But from what I've seen, Carrie Underwood is the preferred, in my opinion.

She is beautiful, talented, and classy, as well as intelligent.

I prefer her voice over Jessica's, and I take her more seriously than I would take Jessica.

Answer 23

My definite choice would be Carrie Underwood. Tony can make the choices he wants to make. He'll either regret it or not, but I would definitely regret it =]. I don't dislike Jessica though. Well, not much.

Answer 24

Carrie Underwood. I hate Jessica Simpson because

of what one her shirts said "REAL GIRLS EAT MEAT".

Like wtf dude, that is mean. I don't eat meat, that still

makes me a real girl.

Answer 25

I think Carrie is a better singer, but Jessica has everything else.

Answer 26

Carrie Underwood.Carrie has better styel and good songs and the vocie.

Answer 27

Carrie Underwood by far!!!!, Jessica is such a s**t!!

Answer 28

CARRIE UNDERWOOD... no competition  

Answer 29

carrie underwood

Answer 30

Carrie Underwood, she was too good for him anyway