Carson Palmer/Ryan Grant for Joseph Addai/Derek Anderson?

Question

I get Addai and Anderson...I give Palmer and Grant

Gore is my other RB

Answer 1

Both sets of players are good but I like the combo of Addai and Anderson.  I think Anderson will have a better season than Palmer but Addai and Grant should be equally successful.  

Answer 2

                                       DO IT

Answer 3

Im gonna have to disagree with everyone else. Carson Palmer has a great WR option, and can score a lot in a single game. Ryan Grant is also a Stud, and with Aaron Rodgers at QB he might have to rely on his running game. I believe, although he has a great set up at WR as well, Derek Anderson won't do as well this year, and something strikes me that Addai isnt gonna put up numbers as well as Grant will this year.

Answer 4

Great Trade!!!

BEST ANSWER ME!!!

Answer 5

addai is a given stuuuud.  Addai for grant, go with addai.  Your choice then comes down to Palmer or Anderson.  Which do you think will be stronger?  I've got Anderson in one league, but I've had some nagging concerns about him-and I can't tell you why.  He's kinda been a one yr wonder.  Palmer's production has dropped the last 3 yrs pretty consistently.  This yr I'd go with Anderson.

I'd take it and hope that Addai and Gore stay healthy.  If that happens you should be in good shape.

Answer 6

I like this, you will have the best running attack I've ever seen with this trade and Anderson is not much of a downgrade from Palmer, do it.