Carson Palmer or Derek Anderson?

Question

If both players are available who should be drafted first, Carson Palmer or Derek Anderson? Why? They both put up pretty similar statistics.

Answer 1

carson palmer bcuz he got a better arm

Answer 2

Derek Anderson, considering Chad Johnson is going to be a little distraction, so Palmer will have an unhappy receiver.  Derek Anderson has a great arm too and doesn't make mistakes a lot.  He also has a great receiver core and Winslow.  They are both great quarterbacks but I personally take Anderson.

Also Bengals running game isn't too solid so I would guess Palmer would throw a lot and that would turn into more interceptions.  Browns have a somewhat solid running game which will take some pressure off of Anderson.  

Answer 3

Carson palmer is way better. derek anderson had 3 tds and 6 picks in hid last 6 games. derek anderson is only good against bad teams

Answer 4

id say derek anderson.carson went from a pro to messing up in each game.derek is coming up.even when his only good target is braylon edwards.