Chase Headly or Jay Bruce?

Question

Chase Headly or Jay Bruce?

Answer 1

Jay Bruce. They're both top prospects but Bruce has already proven himself.

Answer 2

As of this writing it is obviously Jay Bruce. Bruce had only won POY in the minors and was the MVP of a futures game. Headly has potential but Bruce has the better of the protection in the Reds batting lineup than Headly.

Advantage: Bruce

Answer 3

Jay Bruce

He's a better prospect with potential to put up better numbers than Headley. Headley is great and all but he plays in PETCO for 81 games. Not an easy place to put up impressive offensive numbers. Bruce is in a better ballpark and his hot start is showing his potential to be great. Headley is great too but Im more confident in Bruce.