Question:

Chris Judd, Best ever Blue?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

Is Chris Judd the best Carlton Footballer of all time?

 Tags:

   Report
Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

20 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date  |  Rating

  1. He might make their top 10 by the time he retires, but best ever, um, don't think so.


  2. No way! yea he's a good player, but half the time he just stands there and waits for other people to do his work. yea he kicks a couple of goals and gets in a few kicks but hes no were neatr the best player on the Carlto n team. in my opinion Brendon Fevola, Nick Stevens, Matt Krueszer and Marc Murphy are the better players.

  3. hardly he's done nothing scene he's been there

  4. He he he, best question ever asked in the "dumb ***" category....  Luv ya like a bruther from anuther muther.

  5. being still so young he probably will be, there have been some beauties though, jezza, southby,doull, just a couple to name, next year barring injuries we will see his best,  he will be back to his unstoppable best, love to watch that guy take on the chaser etc.

  6. WHy does everyone think he is a god at carlton. Hes a great player but come on hes not that great get over yourselves carlton you've got a long way to go

  7. you gotta be joking cant kick over 30 meters cant mark overhead weak handball most overrated footballer i have everseen if it wasnot for cousins kerr stengline and co he wood never have won a brownlow

  8. ROFLMAO.

    Lets see if he EVER captains a premiership side first.

    On that basis alone Stephen Kernahan has the wood on Judd already.

    Carlton will be very unlikeley to win a premiership in the next decade with or without Judd or whoever they can get as priority draft picks....

  9. This is a question best asked at the end of the season or the end of his career. I am not much of a Carlton supporter but you are missing out on great players like, Steven Kernahan, Steve Silvania, Jezalenco, Kouta and the likes of these all time greats.

    Honestly, Judd's best footy has been over West, give him time before you start labeling him for the Blues. Chances are he will improve the his injury getting better but not wisihng harm on him but if he goes down, blown out knee or something that ends his career he will only be one of the most expensive players for the Blues.

  10. Lets give him a few more seasons before anyone gives him that title. Being a great player is about consistency throughout your career. He's a good player (one of the best going round today).... but his career hasn't ended yet.

  11. BIG CALL!,after 3 games for the club

    mate what about champions like Greg Williams who is a dual brownlow winner,premiership player/norm smith,stiff not to have 3 brownlows and a bloke who racked up 40+ possession games like few could.

    juddy is a gun but at 24 and with years ahead of him lets wait and see before we start carrying on just yet.

  12. That sounds like something that egg head mike sheean would say. Judd is a good player but not the blues best.

    i am not a blues fan but heres a list of players i think were good

    sos(not sure how to spell his name)

    jezza

    bradley

    doul

    kernahan

    deitrich

    maybe in a few years we can answer that question thats if judd stays at the blues

  13. No.

    I think it's an insult to previous Blues players to classify Judd as the best ever Blue ------AFTER THREE GAMES!!!!!

  14. very unlikely this will ever be the case... Carlton do not have enough strength in its engine room to clear a path for Judd as was the case at West Coast...  great player.. yep..  best ever..  no chance!

  15. way to earlier to say maybe ask this q in about 15 years

  16. he's only played three games for the blues so how can you possibly say he's the best player that they have ever had. you would have to say judd has been the best player for west coast but he's yet to play his best at carlton.

  17. LMAO!!!!

    PROBABLY!!!!   lol

  18. i think he will be by the end

  19. Over-rated and over- publicised !!

  20. he has played three games... somehow I don't think you can tell if someone is going to turn out to be the best Carlton Footballer of all time after that :)

    your forgetting about Jazza, Kouta and lots of others.

    wait till he's played a few years, you never know.. he might turn out to be the biggest, most expensive flop of all time. lol
You're reading: Chris Judd, Best ever Blue?

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 20 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Register Now