Question:

Chris Judd back to Victoria? what do you think?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

there's talk carlton would offer a million a year over 5 years and give away a young player plus pick 3 in the draft as a carlton supporter i hope we don't-surely one player isn't worth all that?

 Tags:

   Report
Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

12 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date  |  Rating

  1. Send him out Geelong way Forky if the Blues don't need him.  The VFL side has been having trouble finding runners :-)

    Short (not so smug answer) answer "no".  Certainly not until he proves resilience from the current injury.  I don't think the Blues need players anyway.  They need attitude.


  2. I think Judd is a legend. Though I think he should stay at West Coast, thats where he kicked off his carear and is well known to be, thats where I think he'll stay. But if they're going to send him anywhere... kick him over to Collingwood =D

  3. According to the Vic's he is and it might stop them whinging about him playing over in WA when I was in Melbourne the most common thing I was heard was Judd is a Victorian he should be playing here forgetting Nathan Buckley is a SA.

    If he goes anywhere I think it  will be Collingwood  Eddie McGuire would have already started the process by giving his girlfriend a job at channel nine and they are in the financial position to get him.

  4. judd is worth it trust me. there are alot of teams that would love to have him. it was inevetable that he was to come back to melbourne.

  5. yeh, hes going to carlton and hes getting 7 million dollars amazing hey. you should of seen john worsefolds face on 7 news lol. im happy coz eagles will be **** and dockers will beat em with ease and mark harvey is dockers new coach woohooo.

    good on ya juddy, for leaving a drug addicted team!

  6. the saints,they have the money to intice him.

  7. I think judd will sign with the eagles soon. no hope of coming back to melbourne

  8. If any of you have ever lived in WA you would understand...I don't know how he has survived this long in this parochial little town in the middle of nowhere! Can't wait to venture out tomorrow and see all the stunned looks on the locals faces! Ps- on local TV news people on the street are already laying in the boot and calling him a traitor for leaving "his"team! Typical!

  9. How about Fevola + Pick #3? - the Weagles are desperate for something up forward and have an embarassment of riches in their midfield and may not feel the absence of Judd quite like another side would.

    Carlton would then have the makings of a sensational midfield - Judd, Stevens, Carozzo, Kreuzer etc and the WCE would finally have a forward who would relish being on the receiving end of precise delivery as well as a handy young pick...

  10. He will regret it

  11. Yeah, I reckon he`s worth that. Only 24, he has a lot to offer. I would be happy if the Tigers gave up picks to get him. I know its best to go with a youth policy, but this is an exceptional case.

  12. COME TO HAWKS JUDDY !!

    WE WANT JUDDY IN YELLOW AND BROWN

    hehehe

    i actually feel sorry for kids who go for west coast they all have number 3 on there backs . I wonder who they will have now ?
You're reading: Chris Judd back to Victoria? what do you think?

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 12 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Register Now