Chris Judd - superstar or super hype?

Question

Chris Judd - superstar or super hype?

Answer 1

I think ghe is definitely a super star. Last year he didnt play well at all because he was injured.

At Carlton probs didnt deserve the captaincy because he should have to prove himself to the team first.

Good Luck to him anyway, my team WC helped him alot in the game by giving him space so lets see how well Carlton can manage and see if he is the best player in any team. But yeah Good Luck to him, glad we ever had him at West Coast =]

Answer 2

There are 18 players on the arena, not only Chris Judd.  Can't see his team "mates" bringing him into the play, just so that he can look spectacular.

Judd will have to work hard at Carlton because all eyes will be on him to perform.

This can be a lot of weight on his shoulders, and hinder his style of play.

After all, Judd is not a true Blue.

Answer 3

Over-rated.

Cox smacking the ball down your throat, Cousins and Kerr getting the ball for you, yes he will struggle. Carlton have no quality and no heart.

Answer 4

We are possibly not the ones best qualified to judge - when AFL players were asked to nominate their best player - in late 2006, Judd was overwhelmingly the favourite, beating any other by more than 20%.....I believe over 400 players were polled. Good enough for me

Answer 5

dont know why the jealousy has started with juddy, there is know question that he is a superstar, i dont barrack for carlton or west coast, in fact my team, missed him aswell, but give credit where its due, he is a 'true' brownlow medal winner, unlike a few i can off the top of my head.

brad hardie, greame teasdale, gerard healy, he deserved his, wish he was at my club and not bloody carlton.

Answer 6

The first time i saw him was against Bribane in 2002. I couldn't remember seeing a footballer do what he did that day (especially for a person of his age).

I think he's easily the best i've seen, he is NOT overrated in anyway whatsoever. He has an incredible turn of foot, an ability to burst through stoppages (I think he'd win the Oakleigh Plate if they nominated him), great vision, brilliant decision making, a huge engine, sublime skills, and kicks goals...So basically, he's the perfect footballer...

He's a freak of nature. So anyone talking him down is just sour grapes. He'll go down in history as the best player to have played this game IMAO...

Answer 7

yes hes a super star was for the west coast hope he a super star for the blue

Answer 8

SUPER HYPE!  For sure!!

like I said in my last answer re. Judd, someone please pass me a bucket - makes me sick!!

Answer 9

No doubt genuine superstar. The real deal has record to prove it and will do a Greg Williams and win a Brownlow at some stage with Carlton

Answer 10

THE MEDIA DO WHAT THE MEDIA DO,Juddy is a gun no question and rated not just by the Media but also by current players who have played on and against him,plus former greats who put him amongst the best they've seen.

he had a year where he was injured which is quite common amongst AFL players but if he comes back fully fit i have no doubt he will continue to be one of the best players in the comp.

Its not his fault the media love to create hype.

Answer 11

superstar now that hes on carlton

Answer 12

Fully fit he is a superstar, and will be a stand out at Carlton.

But super hype too, there are more players than him in the AFL ........ I thought it was a team sport.

Answer 13

Was a superstar at WCE, but with his recent injuries will become Super hype at CFC.

Answer 14

He is a star

there is not a more complete midfielder than him

he has excellent skills on the ground and in the air

a superb kick, and great on the hands

he is very quick and very balanced

always keeps his feet

and most importantly...is a game breaker...can do the impossible and win matches on his own boot.

Answer 15

Super Star