Chris Judd v West Coast?

Question

Is Chris Judd weak for leaving the west coast eagles at such a bad time for the club?

Answer 1

No. If there is a culture problem within an organisation and you don't have the power to change it, it's better to change your own situation if you don't want to be a part of it.  Was Peter Costello weak for refusing to take over the leadership of the Liberal Party after the last election?

Answer 2

no he just wanted to come back to melbourne

Answer 3

no he just wanted to come

but he is weak for joining those poser's carlton

Answer 4

No if he wanted to leave good on him i mean look at West Coast now they are tanking.

Answer 5

I don't think that it had anything to do with the club, it was a personal decision that he was planning to make for a long time. The circumstances at the Eagles had nothing to do with the fact that he wanted to come back to Melbourne.

Answer 6

no he justed wanted to move back to his home and play for a melbourne team  

Answer 7

I, as a WCE supporter, hold no grudge against Juddy for leaving. However, I do have my doubts that it was because of homesickness. I feel he left because of all the c**p that went on and he did not want to tarnish his rep any further. Sad that he left us at such a bad time? - For sure!! Weak? not really. But, so far we had the best of Juddy. Hopefully he can return form his injury problems and play that level consistently again.

(Oh, and Daniel Kerr will not leave us. At least that it what I am choosing to believe and praying will happen..)

Answer 8

No way, id get out too if i was playing under those circumstances. talk of getting kerr to go too

Answer 9

Weak or smart?

Weak is the new smart

Answer 10

no is not weak because he want to play for a driffernt team