Comfort back on So You Think You Can Dance?

Question

Hi, see, last night when I watched So You Think You Can Dance, I was wondering where Jessica was? Comfort was back! What happened there? So, I found out she broke her ribs, and her doctor said she couldn't continue to dance on the show! :( So sad for her! The thing I'm wondering, is, even if she really did break her ribs, could another reason she finally decided the pain from her rib was too much, be about what Mia said? If you don't remember, she quoted, "Jessica is bringing you down, I bet you're tired after lifting HER so much. You need a new, light partner". I could tell Jessica was about to burst out crying! How mean! So, what I'm wondering, is, do you think that another reason Jessica left was because of that? And, if you don't, don't you still think that was mean of Mia? Opinions, please!

Answer 1

I didn't care for Jessica's dancing but I do think Mia is not a very good judge.   Nigel can be stern, but fairly judges performances bad or good.  Mia on the other hand seems to be a bit heartless in her critiques.  That whole bit about Kherrington smiling too much a couple weeks ago?  She went on and one about it.  I didn't think it was a big deal, but she really put a damper on the whole performance with her critique.  I loved the third judge last night.  He was an excellent judge and should replace Mia in my opinion.

Oh, and I  think Will didn't do a great job last night even without Jessica as his partner.  Honestly, everybody seemed a little 'off' in their performances.  I just love Gev, but he missed a huge step in his solo.  I was so upset for him!

(I doubt Jessica left because her feelings were hurt.  Although I have to admit that possibility crossed my mind too!)

Answer 2

I really don't think she wouls "fake her ribs being cracked" I agree  I think Jesica should have gone but America has the final vote and they liked her, I hope Comfort goes home this week for good.  She can't dance and if she stays then America voted wrong.  

About Mia she is an awesome teacher but as a judge she is terrible, I think she should not be a judge.  Who knows the real reason.

Answer 3

That was my first thought as well.  All of the judges have been unnecessarily brutal to her. Mia Michaels was totally out of line saying that there is a way to criticize people with out being extremely mean and cutting someone down like that.  She is not the best dancer on the show but she did good.  I felt so bad for her when Mia said that.

Answer 4

Okay, well...

Your getting an aswer from somebody that is not a big fan of Jessica!!

I thought it was kinda true on what Mia said but she could of said it in an other way.

But once again, these judges jobs are to say the truth and the dancers should be able to take that critisim, shake  it off and start picking up the paste.

That's what the SHOW IS ABOUT!!

CONGRATS COMFORT AND WILL ;)! BUH-BYE TO JESSICAA!!