Could Shaq and Kobe won a title without Phill Jaskson?

Question

People always say Kobe can't win without shaq but the truth is they both couldn't have won without Phill.

3 titles with Phill proves that.

Tell me what you think ?

Answer 1

Actually yes............If you didn't know FYI Shaq won with the Heat (coach pat riley) in 2006!!! So ya I guess Shaq can but Kobe yet to be seen I bet he could to though

Answer 2

Great question!  I'd have to say based on their talent at the time they played together, yes, I believe that could have won with just about any coach.  Those teams were pretty good to begin with.  I think Phil gets too much credit sometimes.  After all he also had MJ.  I think I could have won with those teams!

Answer 3

Yes . If they had Pat Riley or Greg Popovich...

Phil Jackson is Great Coach .. but so is Popovich and Pat Riley ..But i think Phil is better tho

I think they are better duo than Jordan and Pippen ... IF they were together at their Prime like Jordan and Pippen did .. remember Kobe was only in his yearly 20's when they had 3 peat

Well Lakers made to Semifinals twice and WC Finals once w/o Phil

Answer 4

To borrow a phrase from Reggie Jackson, Phil was "[T]he straw that stirs the drink."

There would have been to many ego issues without Phil's calming, "Zen Master" approach.

I think the three of them were at the right place, the right time, with the right people supporting them.

Next question: would Phil have come back to the Lakers this year, if he did not have a relationship with Jeannie Buss?

Answer 5

That's a good questions i never taught of that Phil Jackson has always bee a good Coach in my Opinion and i think they could of won 1 or 2 Nba Champs ,b tu Jackson is that coach gives the that push

Answer 6

Shaq won with Riley ... answer is SHAQ could , Kobe Can't.

Answer 7

I think Shaq and Kobe could've won without Phil, but not 3 straight times. They would've won 1 or 2. Kobe and Shaq were together 4 years before Phil got there... And they did nothing without him.  

Answer 8

Lakers or the Bulls could not win without Phill Jaskson!!

Answer 9

show these people the video of kobe scoring 81, and then have them tell me that hes nothing without shaq. phill is great. with whatever team he coaches, he makes their record a h**l of a lot better. i agree with you 110%.

Answer 10

What are you talking about they can't win without Phil Jackson? Shaq won another ring in Miami...Kobe hasn't done c**p without Shaq though.