Could people who think Judd will go to collingwood try and explain to me how would it work?

Question

as i see it,it would be a hard deal to get done because

1.west coast have said publicly they don't want to deal with the pies

2.collingwood don't have any picks in the top 10 to trade with

3.that would mean eagles would wan't at least 2 yound players from collingwood i.e thomas and pentelbury which collingwood wont do

so tell me how you think it could work if at all???

Answer 1

1. Judd was a fan of Collingwood as a young boy so he would enjoy playing for the pies

2. Collingwood are a quality team that was one goal away from being in the grand final this year

2. Collingwood already have stars like Thomas, Pendelbury, Shaw brothers, Buckley, Rustling, Rocca, Cloke e.t.c Juddy would be a great addition to their ruck as a rover possibly replacing Shane O'Bree as one of their current rovers

3. Why would Juddy want to go to Carlton...wooden spooners 05, 06 and 1 loss away from 07

I rest my case.

Answer 2

Not gonna happen!

Answer 3

No Ifs Whys and Buts .

MONEY TALKS!!!!!!

Answer 4

easy question

People thinks Judd will go to collingwood. Because Chris goes for collingwood when he was young.

Answer 5

The Pies don't want to pay what the Eagles want for him so negotiations have broken down so guess what Forky I think he will be playing for the Blues next year which I would much prefer than seeing him in the black and white.

I think Eagles will get Carltons third pick ironical really because Judd was third pick in the draft.

Chris Judd barracked for Melbourne as a boy and one of his childhood hero's is Gary Lyon.

Answer 6

You're right.  It won't.

You'll read his name on the Blues injury list next year with 'season' next to it.  No disrespect intended - I just feel that he's damaged himself by playing so hard and tough for 5 or 6 years or whatever it is.  If I was the CEO of one of these clubs, I'd be saying 'no', but I'm not ... so there :-P