Critique my Fantasy Football Draft?

Question

I had the 5th overall starting pick, also my computer crashed after the 6th round (only for one round) but oh well here it is:

rd 1, pick 5 - Steven Jackson

rd 2, pick 6 - Maurice Jones-Drew

rd 3, pick 5 - tony romo

rd 4, pick 6 - greg jennings

rd 5, pick 5 - jason whitten

rd 6, pick 6 - kevin curtis

rd 7, pick 5 - jay cutler (computer crashed)

rd 8, pick 6 - lee evans

rd 9, pick 5 - anthony gonzalez

rd 10, pick 6 - jacksonville

rd 11, pick 5 - josh scobee

rd 12, pick 6 - warrick dunn

rd 13, pick 5 - reggie williams

rd 14, pick 6 - tennessee

rd 15, pick 5 - shaun mcdonald

Answer 1

I like the first 3 picks.

Im not sold on Jennings especially w/o Favre.There had to be a better option.

Witten is Great

Way way way too early for Curtis

Cutler will be solid and rd.7 is about right for him

I like Gonzalez but again way too early..you are reaching at wr

The rest of the picks are just so s****.>
I give you a 7

Answer 2

I give it a 5, a weak 5 for not having a top notch WR.  Picking Romo as a 3rd round pick was a bad move.  You could have picked him around the 5th or 6th round.  I don't agree picking up Jennings over Witten since Jennings doesn't have a reliable QB.  I would trade for a top tier WR to balance out your team.

Answer 3

This is how your line-up looks:

Starting:

QB - Tony Romo

RB - Steven Jackson

RB - Maurice Jones-Drew

WR - Greg Jennings

WR - Lee Evans

WR - Kevin Curtis

TE - Jason Witten

K - Josh Scobee

D/ST - Jacksonville D/ST

Bench:

QB - Jay Cutler

RB - Warrick Dunn

WR - Anthony Gonzalez

WR - Reggie Williams

WR - Shaun McDonald

D/ST - Tennessee D/ST

______________________________________...

QB - Romo in Round 3 is awesome. Jay Cutler is a good back-up for Romo. 8/10

RB - Your tandem of Steven Jackson and MJD is very good.  Warrick Dunn won't see much playing time though. 8/10

WR - You have too many wide receivers. Greg Jennings should have another good year in Green Bay. Kevin Curtis should also have another big year. Lee Evans disappointed a lot of people last year, but I think that he'll bounce back from it. Anthony Gonzalez should have a better year than last year. Reggie Williams and Shaun McDonald aren't worth owning in fantasy football. 7/10

TE - Jason Witten is the best tight end in fantasy football, but getting him in Round 5 is a big reach. You probably could have gotten him in round 7 or even later. You need a back-up for him. 7/10

K - You can do better than Josh Scobee. 6/10

D/ST - Both of your defenses are good. 9/10

______________________________________...

Tips:

Look to trade - Josh Scobee, Warrick Dunn, and Reggie Williams

Look to trade for - K and 2 RB

Drop - Shaun McDonald

Pick-up - TE

______________________________________...

Your final line-up should look like this:

Starting:

QB - Tony Romo

RB - Steven Jackson

RB - Maurice Jones-Drew

WR - Greg Jennings

WR - Lee Evans

WR - Kevin Curtis

TE - Jason Witten

K - ********* (not Josh Scobee)

D/ST - Jacksonville D/ST

Bench:

QB - Jay Cutler

RB - ********** (not Warrick Dunn)

RB - **********

WR - Anthony Gonzalez

TE - *********

D/ST - Tennessee D/ST

______________________________________...

Overall Team Grade: 7/10

Answer 4

First off,you didn't reach to get Witten.And he WOULDN'T have been there in the 6th,or 7th round.Anyone who thinks other wise hasn't drafted a team this year.

I give your team a 7.5...After K.Curtis your picks were very questionable.(Good insurance against computer crashes is to place targetted players you like in the que column.)

I suggest packaging starters+benchers for opponents' better starters.(Treat benchers as barter chips to improve your starters,then replentish your bench with high potential/reward

sleepers.) For instance offer: Jay Cuttler+Lee Evans for Tory Holt,,,then get a diff. back up QB off of waivers.(Your starters win/lose leagues 4-U,,not back ups!)~~G{}{}d Luck!