Curtis Joseph: Where will he rank amongst the the best players to never win a Cup as a player?(once he retire)

Question

CuJo has signed with the Toronto Maple Leafs and it looks like he will retire without a cup when it is said and done. Unless if by the trade deadline of next hockey season he is traded to big contender to just go along for the ride!!

Answer 1

Eh....he had some good years but personally i don't think he had a hall of fame career....ie 10 years after he retires no one will really remember him....

Answer 2

He's never been that dominate except for a couple of seasons.  I doubt he's a Hall of Famer.

Answer 3

am I the only one who remembers that Cujo came through the US college system (one year at University of Wisconsin) AND came into the leauge UNDRAFTED without playing Major Junior hockey? (I don't think the OJHL is up to par with the OHL is it?)

Answer 4

Cujo still has a chance to win the Cup, in theory. But, let's be honest, the Leafs ain't gonna go to the big dance any time soon.

In terms of his Hall of Fame props, he'll be considered a solid journeyman. h**l make it into the Hall, but probably not until the 3rd or 4th vote.

Answer 5

Hey, he's playing with the Leafs this season. He still has a chance to win the cup before he retires.

lol. Looking at some of the players who have never won the cup, I wouldn't rank him near the top ten.

Answer 6

He's been a top 10 goalie since he started in the league. Not a superstar(maybe top 5 as an early leaf)but always consistent.

Answer 7

HE IS A SELL OUT and plays just for the $$$ - no hall of fame or anything - NO HEART = NO PROPS