DO I win in this fantasy baseball trade?

Question

There are 2 trades that I am thinking about doing: TRADE A sending Yuel Escobar, Jay Bruce, and Brandon lyon for

Michael Young and Cliff Lee.

OR

TRADE B

Should I make the deal if I send those three player but in return I get Felix Hernandez and Michael Young?

I need starting pitching since my league is a rotisserie league. I losed Chien Mein Wang, Shaun Marcum and Fasuto Carmona to the dl. PLease tell me what you chose is the best trade to help me. 10pts for best answer.

.

Answer 1

Cliff Lee is more seasoned and is probably the real deal now.  I think he is a solid choice with less risk.  King Felix however is young and has been in the league almost a year about the amount of time it takes for hitters to adjust to him.  With that said he has great stuff and a lot of upside.  His throwing motion at the top is rachety though and with your luck and DL problems that might be the deciding factor.  In conclusion I say Lee...Simply on a better team with a chance for run support to pick up W's

Answer 2

Get Cliff Lee... Bruce is nice to trade because he is just trade bait with his big debut... go with A  look at the Mariners record they suck

Answer 3

Honestly both trades get you some good pitching, I have both Cliff Lee and King Felix on my team and both are doing great. Although both pitchers teams are struggling. The only thing is that King Felix is injured and out for his Tuesday start so i dont know if it will long until he comes back. Cliff Lee is 11-1 with 90 K's and 16 BB's whereas King Felix is 6-5 with 93K's and 38 BB's. Both are good K machines, but with Felix being injured right now I would go with the Cliff Lee deal. You are definetly getting more out of this deal although you are losing 3 players. Take the Cliff Lee deal!

Answer 4

Your crazy if you don't take trade A Common it's not even close Push the button man

Answer 5

Take trade A...if baseball suddenly ended today...Lee is a lock for the Cy Young...right now he's the best pitcher in baseball and doesn't appear to be slowing down...

Answer 6

wow. you lost some serious SP'ers to the DL, dude.  Remember, King Felix ALSO was injured at the end of his last start; he twisted his ankle while trying to cover first.   I think you're smart to use the "Jay Bruce" name to gain a proven, veteran player or two.  Trade away Bruce, Escobar, and Lyon for Young and Lee.