Deuce M or Rudi J; Pats defense or Chargers defense?

Question

I have the choice to start Deuce or Rudi in my 2nd RB spot. Deuce is a solid runner coming off an injury and Rudi is a streaky runner who went to Detroit (where careers go to die.) Rudi is at least running against the falcons where Deuce gets the Buccaneers. Tough call.

As for defense, Chargers get a Steve Smith-less Panthers, Patriots get an always-awful Kansas City.

Answer 1

I'd definitely start Deuce. He's still the power back on the Saints and will get the Goal Line carries. Reggie Bush and Pierre Thomas are both the same style of runners and will only be effective for 3rd down passing downs.

Rudi is still hurt and he's got a new team he has to work with. Kevin Smith looks good and will start.

I'd play the Pats against KC. KC's O Line looks horrible and when the Pats go up ahead they'll be forced to throw and Croyle will make a ton of mistakes.

Hope that helps!

~Mark Lim

www.PoisonApple.com

Answer 2

Rudi probably won't get more than 5 carries or so as he still has to learn the offense.  On the season he will be better but not this week.

Answer 3

i would choose Duece... and the Chargers...... Rudi doesnt know the offense yet.... and it'll take awhile before he even gets to split carries.. and Duece is at least getting 50/50 with Bush....