Dhoni is letting down the powerful Indian test batting line up of the famed FAB 5? WHO CAN REPLACE HIM?

Question

In dhonis last 12 innings hes had scores of 0, 11, 2, 35, 19, 38, 16, 20, 16, 14, 52 and 32.

So Dhoni has been averaging less than 22, in his last 12 innings. That is pathetic, considering indias Fab 5 have all been averaging over 44, in there last 12 innings.

Sehwag has been averaging 72 in his last 12 innings

Dravid has been averaging 46 in his last 12 innings

Sachin has been averaging 63 in his last 12 innings

Ganguly has been averaging 44 in his last 12 innings

Laxman has been averaging 48 in his last 12 innings

23 hours ago

Maybe the likes of karthick and partiv patel should slowly take his place.

Dhonis carer average is 33, Meanwhile Karthick carer average when he was dropped was 42, and he was also an opener.

If india play karthick as a wicket keeper batsman only in test, and opening at the top of the order, than india can also play irfran pathan more regulary, to accomadate 5 bowlers. Is that a good idea

Answer 1

Averages are only for statistic books but Karthik is a good replacement for Dhoni if he loses form or favour and as everyone knows that either can happen to anyone. As far as captaincy in the shorter version there are at 2 contenders - Yuvraj & Ganguly, so Dhoni is dispensable if either his bat gets thinner or head thicker. As regards his remarks about the top 5 in test cricket, it is an immature and irresponsible statement which would never have been tolerated if he hadn't been captaining the winning side of the T20 World cup.

Answer 2

Dhoni is setting out to the ruin team India that was started by Chappell and rahul.

He is better as a wicket keeper; that is what he is.

agreed that Parthiv Patel has been batting better than Dhoni. But  his wicket keeping is not as good. He is also very short. .

Dhoni has proved a good Captain so far. he is also in the good books of selectors.

Answer 3

none can excel dhoniiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

Answer 4

Dhoni can't be replaced. Good luck. May god bless you.

Answer 5

dhoni is a wicket keeper...so no body

or

parthiv patel      

he is in a good form now........