Did INDIA Lose because of Inexperience or Dhoni?

Question

Was it Dhonis painfully very slow innings on a Flat track that lost india the game, or was it the inexperinced and young bowlers and the inexpierenced Raina and Pathan who made 1 and 0.

There is no Doubt Sachin, Bhaji and Zaheer Khan are missed, Maybe even Dravid and Ganguly

Answer 1

both

Answer 2

because of poor batting in middle order, poor bowling performance~

Answer 3

India lost because of dhoni.Yes,we don't have experienced bowling attack from zaheer,bhajji etc &also present pacers are not doing good job.It is dhoni's fault that we lost the match.Dhoni even in the end overs played slowly to try to be the not out batsmen.Dhoni’s was a selfish effort.He play himself in(and for much too long) and to get into form.He is not in form except that 100 vs hong kong and so he played selfish innings putting his personal interests ahead of the Indian team.And the commentators clearly stated that it was a flat track to bat on.He should have  played like younis khan but he feared he might lose his wicket even aftr scoring fifty & he played slowly in the end overs.And a good 325 was expected in this flat track,anyone would have grabbed the opportunity to play in this track ,had he not played in that fashion on such a flat track,india had a chance of posting a good total.He put his personal interests ahead of the team.

He has been lucky for sometime,he would have made things even worser for the team had he dropped sehwag yesterday.

Answer 4

They lost because the bowlers were not good enough. 308 should be a competitive score but I think that even 350 would have been chased down such was the ease that the Pakistani bats scored.

Answer 5

It was mostly Dhoni's fault. That was an extremely flat pitch and Dhoni made no effort to increase the run rate. Pakistan walked it in the end because of the low total they were set.

Answer 6

Pakistan won? OMG, such things as dreams are made of! To answer your Q, p**i must have played better on the day!

Answer 7

The way Pakistan batted, even they could have chased the score of 350 runs and won the match.  Hence I attribute poor bowling by India which cost th4e match than anything else.

Answer 8

India lost because of poor batting in middle order, poor bowling performance and due to some resurgence batting by Pakistan top batsmen

Answer 9

Inexperience "sometimes" works as it did in Australia. But of course, fairy tale victories don't happen all the time.

So, India lost because of Dhoni and inexperience. Dhoni is at fault because he is the reason for supporting inexperienced players.

Answer 10

I think india lose because of poor batting in middle order, poor bowling performance

Answer 11

i dont think so that India losed because of Dhoni

I think they losed because of their bowling