Dimitar Berbatov vs. Klaas Jan Huntelaar.......?

Question

who'd be the better signing for Man United ?

Answer 1

The Hunter.

First off, Huntelaar won't be a headache or another footballing personification of 'Le Sulk'.

He's good for Ajax, and Man Utd can help him improve and make him on fo the best in the Premiership. I can liken Berbatov to Henry. Hit their peaks once, but are past their best.

Answer 2

berbatov

he has been playing in the premier league for 2 seasons already so he wouldnt need anymore time to adapt. he should be able to fit into the squad immediately which is important for us to defend our titles!

Answer 3

Klaas Jan Huntelaar. Both are great players but since Huntelaar is younger and has more potiental so I think he'd be better for us.

Answer 4

Huntelaar all day he's too underated

Berbatov would be a good a signing but Huntaleer's even better  

Answer 5

You know my stand on this, Sir Dave...i've always wanted Huntelaar, but right now either would do...though its looking like none :((

Answer 6

Berbatov. he is young enuf but proven at a hard leage and the same he would stay play in

Answer 7

I'd prefer they get Berba because Huntelaar is better. Berba is so lazy some times it's ridiculous. Huntelaar is class and is much younger.  

Answer 8

Huntelaar.

He's younger than Berbatov, so there's room for improvement.

Cheaper, meaning United will save about £12m compared to the reported £30m Spurs are asking; Huntelaar would cost around £18m.

And most importantly, he's the predator that United have missed since Van Nistlerooy left. Everyone says Huntelaar would be c**p in England, but everyone said that about Van Nistlerooy and look what happened.

Huntelaar's goal record speaks for itself, simply amazing.

Answer 9

Huntelaar will be the better signing for Man United.Both of them have the same finishing style as van Nistelrooy but Huntelaar is younger,quicker and better than Berbatov.You saw how Berbatov played last week against Middlesborough?He was not his usual self.Also Man United's 1-1 draw against Newcastle at Old Trafford showed we need an out-and-out striker,Dave.

Answer 10

Huntelaar

Even though he is not a proven striker in the Premiership, unlike Berbatov, he is still young and has room for improvement. He is a very talented forward with a great scoring record @ Ajax. I think he can vastly improve his skill playing for a club like United

My issues with Berbatov is that he is a bit of a headcase...who knows how he would react on a decision made by SAF that is not to his favour plus he is already at an age where what you see is what you get. Berbatov is at his peak of his talent level and United won't see much improvement out of him. To me, he is not worth the transfer money that United are prepare to pay for him.

Regardless, United do need a pure central striker (like a Van Nistelrooy type role ) with Tevez or Rooney playing just behind them