Do I start darren mcfadden, lendale white or rudi johnson week 1?

Question

Keep in mind who starts and what defense they face.

I know none of these are worthy of starting yet, but the rest of my team is sweet

QB Palmer

RB Tomlinson

RB_________

RB/WR Boldin

WR Wayne

WR Jennings

TE Gonzalez

DST Patriots

K Bironas

BN Santana Moss

BN Ted Ginn

BN Marvin Harrison

BN____________

BN____________

BN Steelers

BN Donald Lee

Answer 1

First off...there probably won't be any scenario in which you'll want to start Rudi this season.  McFadden could be awesome, but he needs to prove he can produce consistently before you rely on him (still don't know how many carries he's getting right now and his offense sucks).  White is the safest bet right now.  This can all change quickly, but for now this is the move you should make.

Good Luck!

Answer 2

1) McFadden will be stopped at 4X yds, won't give you more than 4 points

    Fargas will get the load

2) Rudi won't start but Chris Perry, and will probably be traded.

Lendale White is really your only choice

Answer 3

IF Rudi starts, then he is the choice, if Perry gets the nod over him, then you have to gamble with McFadden.

White against Jax? you can't be serious.

Answer 4

Start LenDale. He is a power back who can put the ball in the endzone and you know what you get with him. Johnson will split carries and so far looks like a non factor this year unless the Bengals suddenly change the RB rotation and McFadden may have talent but if they cant throw the ball with that offensive line he wont have any room to run. Start the season with the guy who has the best opportunity to do well with a team that will rely on the running game.....That leaves you with White in week 1.