Do Port Adelaide supporters want Josh Carr back???

Question

Because they can have ...he played harder there under Mark Williams i think

Answer 1

Say yes! Players who leave the Dockers generally have a career revival! (As opposed to the ones who GO there!)

Answer 2

the real question is do fremantle supporters want josh carr next year.

Josh is a thug, contributes little to the team each week, and isnt getting any younger. Freo are way off a premiership and maybe need to consider getting rid of him to allow a younger, developing player the oppertunity to grow and contribute.

As far as im concerned port or any other club are welcome to take him.  

Answer 3

No thanks. We have moved on, if we had a potentially premiership team he may have been the final cog in the wheel. But we are so far away I cannot see how he will contribute to our younger player development.

Answer 4

What a midfield! The players they already have, plus Carr, Kerr, Cousins and Kadid.  Well Alan is going backwards in his career. And now that Warren is Tredrea-ing water, wouldn't they love it if Buddy sought some buddies at Brighton SA instead of Brighton Vic, and wouldn't they love it if they found some Orange Roughheads in the gulf. Short answer - Yes!.

Answer 5

No. I don't think anyone wants him anymore.

His old habits of behind the play filthy play is well known & the umpires & tribunal are on to him now.

He is too slow to be a force with just his limited ability - he had to be a thug to be of value. Now that aspect of his game is being curtailed he'll just fade quietly away.

Answer 6

He was an amazing player at port adelaide, yet he dominates also at fremantle. So it would be a hard toss up, im an eagles supporter but port adelaide is my third favourite side, so personally if i had to choose to take him back, i would, because over at fremantle he doesnt play 'as' hard as he played under Mark Williams.

I would take him back to port adelaide, thats his home for footy.