Do u think Sharia Law must be abolished, because it is incompatible with norms of modern society?

Question

what i think is that sharia law does not exist in any of the islamic countries. 62 muslim countries and no one is following the sharia.

what are your opinions about it ?

i am in favor of sharia law but just seems like impossible to get it implemented

Answer 1

Could you explain what is sharia law,where do you live?

Answer 2

Sharia, in its present form, is not compatible with principles of freedom and democracy. Twenty-first century Muslims have two options: we can continue the  policies of the seventh century  or we can reform Islam to keep our rich cultural heritage . We, as Muslims who desire to live in harmony with people of other religions, agnostics, and atheists choose the latter option.  We must protect future generations of Muslims from being brainwashed by the Islamic radicals.

Answer 3

Remnanents of the sharia law do exist in almost all of the Islamic countries.

But even if they don't exist at all in any country, it's not the fault of the sharia law, but of the governments that run the Islamic countries.

Answer 4

sharia law is barbaric, oppressive, and inhumane... abolishing it would be a favor to the human race. Its true barely anyone follows sharia because people's logic and innate sense of morality prevents it from being applied.

EDIT: Faraz khawaja, i couldn't agree more, we need more muslims like you.

Answer 5

See this Video; and you'll know how societies are living without Sharia.

http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-M0HhlJwwd...

Answer 6

well don't u need muslims to run the country first? good luck wit that

Answer 7

I agree with tim! It would be like going back to the stone age! No thank you!

Answer 8

THE DAYS OF THE SAHABI ARE OVER! AND WILL NEVER RETURN!

Allah is the judge not any man! Muslim states are communist more than any other state on the face of the earth.

There is nothing wrong with balance, but when you have some dictator above you in threats and warnings against your very choice in freedom.. THEN YOU HAVE EVIL!

Muslim states are of the worst places to live on the face of this earth.I would rather die of hunger than live in any muslim state. As you see so many dying of hunger and suffering at the hands of the leaders in Muslim states that operate this way.  The Zakat is not distributed properly and the Kings are sucking everything you have dry!

Answer 9

Shariah Law Decreed by Allah Allmighty is what we need,it Must Be Implemented by All muslim countries ,with out any fear of angering usa.usa is not our Ela,our Ella is Allah

again there is a conflict which shariah law,sunni or shia ? sunnis wouldnt accepth sharia law in iran or any other country where shias are in majority,shias would accept the same in sunni majority countries just like pakistan ..?

the present day shariah is hadith based,and far from Glorious Quran which itself is a GREAT SIN..

[6:114] Shall I seek other than GOD as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed?* Those who received the scripture recognize that it has been revealed from your Lord, truthfully. You shall not harbor any doubt.

[6:115] The word of your Lord is complete, in truth and justice. Nothing shall abrogate His words. He is the Hearer, the Omniscient.

[6:116] If you obey the majority of people on earth, they will divert you from the path of GOD. They follow only conjecture; they only guess.

shariah must be according to GLORIOUS QURAN ALONE....

most arabs are worst in disbelief and hypocricy,9:97-101..

they follow hadith based laws,and they recite Glorious Quran !! but they do not implement laws stated in Glorious Quran which makes them hypocrits rightly said in verse 9:97-101

now lets come to the modern society,,how does one define moderan society ? just by inventions ,tall buildings,gadgets,and instruments ?



sin is almost as old as a human being,,the sins are the same,as it was a million yrs or 10,000 yrs ago..have  humans changed ? the answer is  NO.yes life styles have changed,now we can cover hundreds and thousands of  miles in less than a day.g**s are not new,,remember sodom and gomorah ? rape,adultery,murder,greed ,are the same as before...

but in the west almost every thing is legal,,like alcohol,s*x,even incest is not a crime any more....nudity is very common,just as it was when fabric was not invented...

@ abul harrith has a habbit of giving kufr fatwas to ever one who doesnt agree with him..as if he is the father of islam,he should have his name abu islam and not abul harrith..

stop practicing this dear abul harrith,you have no authority to call any one kaafir,this call itself is a sin dear brother..

the king can not save his country ,he has made his country so weak,and vulnerable,because he has made west his god,for his own convenience he would denounce israel for his own convenience he would let israel army on saudi land ,this is what happend recently during iraq war,he let israel army on saudi soil.. isnt it true abul harrith ?

again hypocricy !

Answer 10

Shariah law cannot be forced in implementation.  It can only exist in a truly Islamic state, where the Khalifa is appointed by Allah.  This is what happened at the time of the Prophet (sa), and only when that type of a state is re established through winning the hearts, can Shariah law be fully implemented.

The important thing to note about Shariah law is that non Muslims living such a state would be exempt from Shariah law.  One cannot force a religious law on a person who does not follow that religion.

Perhaps in a future such a country will exist, but as of right now, it is impractical and impossible to islamically implement shariah law.

love for all, hatred for none

Answer 11

sharia law must NOT be abolished.  It is more than compatible with norms of modern society.  But one must have an Islaamic state to do so, and as we know, it won't come until the time of Mahdi and Eesa Ibn Maryam.  But they do have some or most practices in few countries, and I think its a good thing... except, its not complete without a khaleef.

So no farther comment as of this moment.

Answer 12

i m not going back to middle stone ages

do wateva u want...lol

stoning ppl to death & chopping hands (shariah law), .is not ok wid me

Answer 13

Yes it should be not utilized as a basis for laws.  As for you favoring the sharia law that's the stupidest idea I have heard all day, Sharia law is backward caveman ideals.  Incompatible with a modern civilized society.  

Answer 14

modern culture is most wicked and thus modern norms should be abolished because it is not compatible with Shariah

Answer 15

That would be Kufr.

And Saudi Arabia's law is Sharee'ah law.

Answer 16

yes please show me an islamic country then we can discuss sharia law.

i am from morocco which is meant to be "islamic" i see more haram in morocco then in the UK and the same goes for all the other arab countries.

islamic country being what??? middle east?? i dont understand how a country is labeled as islamic? because people are arab doesn't mean they are muslim. many who are arab are kuffar or christian. not many muslims. there are more asian muslims then there are arab muslims.

so basically you need to look at what countries are actually islamic. and from my studies at the moment is = 0

i have read about sharia law. its perfect but we need a country where people who are proper practicing muslims live and then we can implement it. and that wont ever happen