Do we really need more Third World people in the USA?

Question

Please explain why you think we need more third world immigrants, legal or otherwise.

Answer 1

We don't need ANY Immigrants at this point in our history.  We don't have land that can be had for homestead, we have very expensive living conditions, and we have a surplus of labor.  Our elected keep telling us we need guest workers.. they can never point to the report that tell us that is the truth.  I think they are ... lying... again....

Infrastructure reports.

http://www.asce.org/reportcard/2005/inde...

http://www.ascecareportcard.org/

http://www.canadafreepress.com/infrastru...

http://www.win-water.org/reports/index.s...

=====================================

More Immigrants is sort of like bringing more people into a sinking boat.  Because Immigrants seldom do well in our society for many reasons, they become welfare recipients and they add their use to the infrastructure, and they add their support costs to our funds.  Right now, it is really dumb to add immigrants.

Answer 2

lol like the people in power care about what YOU THINK you need and dont need

even if you get sick of it, theyre gonna keep coming and coming and coming anyway

and your nation needs them because it makes the economy rise. what can ya do though? your government isnt gonna care about how sick you get of all of them. lmao. too bad. bahahaha. - points n laughs -

Answer 3

No, we don't.

Answer 4

h**l no we don't and I have gotten in the habit of reporting them all.  Just because five or six illegals build  a fence doesn't make up for the increased crime rate and devalued neighborhoods.  I work in retail and although it may be a hard pill to swallow, the most stolen items are latino DVDs and CDs, a large number of the ones caught are illegals.  I getting sick and tired of being paid less because Juan had no respect for the law in the first place.

Answer 5

Yes we do! and Pedro hit some good points on why we need more.

and we're not the only ones that think that either!

http://www.azcentral.com/business/articl...

Illegal immigrants pay taxes, too

Middle Tennessee State University economics professor William Ford, who has studied taxes and immigration, says a majority of economists agree that illegal immigrants are a net benefit for the U.S. economy.

He said the tax contributions from illegal immigrants, including sales taxes, property taxes and excise taxes (such as the gas tax), are significant.

He calculates that illegal immigrants contributed $428 billion dollars to the nation's $13.6 trillion gross domestic product in 2006. That number assumes illegal immigrants are 30 percent less productive than other workers.

"If anything we need more immigrants coming into the country, not less, especially with the baby boomers retiring," he said.

Answer 6

SI SENOR! if you look at the true facts about the ones that are already here, there's proof that they are big contributor to this great country. Not only do they do the work most Americans don't want to do, they pump billions into our economy, they pay billions in taxes and they bring their great cultural beliefs and good food to. We need cultural diversity, or all the food would taste the same, and everybody would look alike.......ewwww!

http://www.usimmigrationsupport.org/cont...

Contributions of Immigrants to the United States

In a report published by the CEA or Council of Economic Advisers, immigrants were found to positively contribute to the U.S. economy. For example, immigrants add more than $30 billion in income for American workers (U.S. born). In terms of innovation per capita, immigrants in the U.S. beat the U.S. born workers. A greater number of immigrants start up businesses compared to native born Americans; their start up pace is estimated to be 40% greater. Other report findings included that immigrants had a lower probability of ending up in prison and committing crimes. It was not surprising that the CEA report found that more workers yield greater output as this would be expected in the United States as with many other nations. Immigrants play a role in the country’s macroeconomic growth and their taxes help increase public budgets. The study found that on average, immigrants and their offspring contribute nearly $80,000 more tax revenue compared to natives. This will help offset the problem that will arise with the nation’s Social Security system but it will not take care of the problem entirely. Due to the large number of “Baby Boomers” retiring in the near future, the number of retirees will outnumber the number of contributors. The Medicare program has also seen an increase in enrollees and will also benefit from more tax revenue coming in.

Answer 7

The USA is the Great Melting Pot. Ours is made up up of all different

nationalities and over the centuries, it has made us great.  Have you read the inscription on the Old Lady, the Statue of Liberty? Take a closer look at it and feel proud you are American!

"Give me your tired, your poor,

your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,

The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.

Send these, the homeless,tempest-tost to me,

I lift my lamp beside the golden door."

Somehow I get a chill when I see 'illegals' herded up like wild horses

and carted away.  These people for the most part only want to work and better their lives.  This is 'America of Now', steadily in decline,

however, the days when the inscription meant something, America

was a surging hope to mankind, a country destined to become Great

beyond measure.  Alas for the good 'ole days'!

Answer 8

nope.

to me third world seems like not very much education and a burden on our system

there should be a points system or you should have to be in school or already have skills(doctor engineer etc)

Answer 9

We need more educated people not the unskilled.

I do not understand why our US government will let the poorest minority people into our country, but not let well educated white people in.

Answer 10

Well, does the world need more poor people? I think once things get a bit more even in the world scenario you can start worrying a bit less about who is coming. Happy people don't want to leave from where they are. Then again you have the richest part of the world, Western Europe, where people move from France to England or Greece to Spain or Spain to Germany for meager benefits to their economy. It won't stop until poor countries stop being quite so poor.

Here's something we might need "them" for

this is important to read :

According to a very interesting article in The Sydney Morning Herald, rich, developed countries with low birthrates are going to have an extremely difficult time defending themselves in the future because there won't be enough young people to recruit to serve in their military services.

Whereas, the United States, by virtue of the Hispanic birthrate, don't share the same dismal future.

The article cited how Richard Armitage, the former U.S. deputy secretary of state, told an Australian audience that this shift in global demographics means national defense policies are going to undergo some serious changes.

To Joel W.: Immigrants tend to end up on welfare??? As a legal immigrant to the US, were you aware that you are EIGHT TIMES more likely to become a millionaire than people who were born here?

http://www.smallbiztrends.com/2006/11/im...

Answer 11

Stop your whining. You were once an illegal immigrant too. NORTH AMERICA BELONGED TO RED INDIANS.

You have no right to complain.

Answer 12

No you don`t but it seems like that 3rd world **** are the only ones interested in immigrating to the U.S these days.

Answer 13

Sure the more that come the less they will be payed cause they will eventually make the reason they come here the reasonthey go back

from whence they came to starve without having to work themselves to death for a buck worth 1/10th it was just four years ago. if they\

keep coming we will still be a strong wealthy country and they still will be wroking their azzets of for the fourty years they live here using up our educational and halth systems until the over burden them to collaspe and our country will still overcome for when they no longer get free medical services from defunct e/r hospitals and maternaty rooms

our government services medical care will have verified medical cards in place only issued thru verified birth certificate based on a new chip tech that cant be forged like a social security number it wi be a birth chip derived from service input from aa government worker and a clip board and a chip made specially for real citizens. So all illegals have

a short time and they will be caught and never again have thought

of protesting in our streets for fear of be rounded up and their

family assets be conficated and their family member made to prove they are legal immigrants with proper documents that will keep their

sad azzets from being shpped back across a border that even though

its a leaky sive wiill require them to make a arduous journey

back into the state they were deported from to try to

find new living spaces since their azzets will have been

taken and sold to other real citizens of this country and 20 miliion

peoples homes and funtirue and clothes and azzets sold to the highest bidder and tooorn down and resold to third world countries

for recycle of the resources and the recoup of the cost to deport

all those illegals no matter how many times they enter.

eventually they will have been depoted enough and finger printed

enough to the warrant being executed for habitual illegal entry

until they either give up or areead for their efforts either due to

being caught up in a altercation with some trigger happy red neck taking turkey shots at night on the this side of the border or some

croked coyote will leave them to die in a whole in the dessert heat until they die a horrible death in the back of a truck due to some

money hungry drug dealer left them loke din some broke down

back of a truck to fdie of thirst or left to the demise of being

lead thru a dessert without water..

Let them come we have something for every sneaking underhanded

coniving idea they can think of to get over they think they are getting over the tide is changing and the government is but one mower

and their azzets are the grass and all grass eventually gets cut down.

in the illegals case is they have a short window now where they think if they are born here to illegals they are citizens but without someone to feed them

the human child takes 18 years to be raised to be self serving and able to support itself and eventuallly they will fallinto need of services and those services are directed by documented support IDs

the new medical system revamp will clearly identify those who are illegals and thats where they will identified and if they protest

fairness we will have ICE and immigration trucks at the ready to deport them in droves in furture they wont even want their born children to

go to school for the documentation will identify them as a illega home and will id ice to stop in one early morning to deport them all back,

its amatter of time and millions to go. 20 million is a start

cheers keep them coming we will get allot of them hard until they die.

or become part of a service program headed that way.

Answer 14

do u think they are not useful? you are totally wrong. do you know who made Greece ready for Olympic games in 2004?