Do you Agree with this ESPN Top 200 Fantasy Football Rankings???

Question

They predict Marshawn Lynch, Marion Barber, and McGahee to do better than Peyton Manning. Rudi Johnson is a #50 pick. Hey they finally got the Chargers defense right as the #1 Defense pick...the last 2 seasons I got the Chargers D off the waiver with my 2 Championships. They told you to not draft the Chargers D the last 2 seasons. DEE DEE DEEEEE

http://sports.espn.go.com/fantasy/football/ffl/story?page=nfl2k8dktop200

Answer 1

No but every website has them ranked different.

Answer 2

Since Rb's score more points in FF then they should have MB3 and McGahee above P.Manning but i dont know if they should have Lynch up there and MB3 and McGahee are like right outside the 1st tier

Answer 3

PAYTON AND ELI SUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 4

No Offense, but they know a lot more than you do. Yes, Payton isn't going to have a good year.

Answer 5

I think the ones you list are pretty solid.  Manning will have a down year.  And remember that it's not necessarily who will get more points - Manning will get more points but lots of QBs will be available, whereas the RBs on the waiver wire will suck.

You can't blame them for not getting the defense stuff right.  That is never accurate in anyone's rankings.

Overall I think they're pretty good.  Here are a few of my disagreements:

1. Lynch and Portis should be ahead of Gore

2. Larry Johnson should be a few slots lower - injury risk and RBBC possibility

3. Jamal Lewis should be higher.  You always start with last year's stats when you rank, and last year Lewis was huge.

4. T.J. Housh should be much higher - I have him at WR #4.  8 is just ridiculous.  I have my doubts about A. Johnson and Fitzgerald but Steve Smith?  No freaking way does he beat Housh.

5. Reggie Bush should be lower - again, you always start with last year's stats.

6. I have Witten ahead of A. Gates.  I don't blame them for that one though.  Gates has a history.