Do you guys think this trade is fair?

Question

I give lendale white, eagles D(he has no D lol cuz we play with a 2 defence leauge and he has one) and reggie williams(or anthony gonzalez)

and he gives me

Brandon Jacobs or Fred Taylor (cant decide which)

And BTW he is weak in the WR area.

im proposing it , what do you guys think is it fair?

Answer 1

You would be giving up way to much on the return here, buddy.   Basically you would be trading pees for carrots, neither of those backs offer that high of retail value.  And, L. White is in the same type of running system as the other two.  If you willing to trade off 3 roster spots shouldn't you be reaching for a higher tier running back...?!?

Answer 2

If you're only getting Brandon Jacobs or Fred Taylor, I would say no. Honestly I would rather have LenDale White than either of those guys.

Answer 3

Trade for Brandon Jacobs not Fred Taylor and other than that the trade doesn't look too bad. But what ever you do dont trade Anthony Gonzalez