Do you hate Carlton and if you do, why?

Question

Should get a few answers I reckon...

Answer 1

Carlton - Growing up the Hawks and Carlton had such an awesome rivalry through September I spent a few Saturday afternoons watching them play for GF spot or for the Cup itself. Hate them ...... yeah but from a rivalry point of view through the 80's

-Go Hawks

Answer 2

Whilst Collingwood is in the AFL I could never hate Carlton

Answer 3

YES!!!,.....I'm an Essendon supporter. Enough said!

Answer 4

I only hate them when Essendon are playing against them and losing!

I do know an Essendon supporter who once trashed his house when Carlton beat the Bombers! Thats passionate!

Answer 5

Well i feel sorry for their supporters because the would frustrate them a bit with their shock losses. Fevola can frustrate sometimes because we all know that his attitude is not hte best..

But personally i dont hate carlton - they have the man that led west coast to a premiership. And i admire some of their players, mainly betts, stevens, fisher, caruzzo & waite.

Answer 6

Yes.

Everyone hates Carlton, don't thay?

I hate them because they try to match Collingwood with arrogance. We are the masters of that practice & the Blues should remember their position in the pecking order.

Answer 7

Always  have, always will. It's so long now i've forgotten the reason, lol, but I hate Collingwood more if that's any help.

Answer 8

I dont hate them but i did not like Whitnall when he played for them.  

Answer 9

I like Carlton. They are my second favourite team.

Answer 10

Their arrogant supporters like Carlton blue boys a who constantly say JUDDDDDDYYYYYYY i can speak on behalf of everyone when i say it is so annoying! They are show offs we they have NOTHING better then any team other team does.

i don't hear hawthorn fans say BUDDDDDDDDDYY

brisbane supporters say BROWNNYY

even tigers supporters say RICHOO

no you don't ever here them say that, and personally i don't remember ever saying JUDDDYYY or CUZZY. That is what really bugs me also they think the are better then everyone, but really they are not at all! Yes they have won there fair share of premierships but since all the interstate clubs have come in they haven't won a thing!

Carlton your not as good as you think you are!!!

Answer 11

Im a mad keen geelong man as you can see. but if I wasnt geelong id sure be on carlton. their such a proud club with great history, great players. I respect them immensly. Collingwood on the other hand?? well no haha

Answer 12

h**l yeah!  Im a Collingwood supporter - its in my blood to hate them.  They are overrated, Fevola the Tool, arrogant supporters.  I will never go to another Pies/Blues game - I always end up close to brawling!!

Asterix, be rest assured that regardless of what team you mention in your Question - all the haters will STILL make it about Collingwood.

If I had asked "Do you hate Richmond"...3/4 of the answers would be Collingwood related.

HATE & MAGPIES go hand in hand..lol

Answer 13

Im a collingwood supporter so i should hate carlton but i dnt really. i actually hate hawthorn.

Answer 14

the only thing i can think of, is that carlton is victorian. and im south australian. OH and i don't like fevola too much

other than that, they have some good players, and tend to have good games against my crows.  

Answer 15

I hate Carlton because I can :)

Nah, I actually do have some valid reasons.

1) Brendan Fevola, enough said

2) Their supporters that stir everyone

3) The fact that they CHEAT/tank!

No hard feelings though mate! Hating Carlton is in the job description of barracking for the Pies! Anyway, what's footy without a little rivalry :)

Answer 16

i should but somehow I don't even though i go for the pies! Strange i know!

Answer 17

of course, why ask the question. Its mandatory for all collingwood supporters to hate them. As for the rest, who cares.

In terms of being the most hated, of course its collingwood. the more that hate us the better we feel

Answer 18

It is hard to say one can hate any team other than Collingwood. I dislike Carlton but when it comes to hate - that is reserved for Bogan-wood, the home of the Maglies.

Carlton rode roughshod over other teams in the old VFL days. There was no salary cap & they were a team, funded by Melbourne's underworld, so had plenty of cash to throw around. They bought players from Tassie, WA & SA & won premierships.

When the AFL & the salary cap tried to reign them into gear president John Elliott thumbed his nose at the rules & continued on his merry way. It took a couple of fines & draft penalties for the decision makers to realize they couldn't compete with Boofhead Elliott running things & they gave him the flick. They are still suffering from those days of Elliott.

Answer 19

Historically Carlton have had such a variety of pratts both on and off the field - John Nicholls springs to mind, as does John Elliott.

They appear to be getting out of the culture that John's rule imposed on them, there are a number of good kids and of course the mighty Judd, and the limitless-when-sober Fevola.

Perhaps there will be a time when there is no reason to hate Carlton - although a few of their so-called fans make it hard. A Carlton fan, sitting in the Essendon reserved section at the MCG, who had been smoking throughout the game, threw a lit cigarette at my companion when asked to stop, and threw a punch at the cop who saw it happen.Whenever Essendon plays Carlton, there are drunks in navy blue a-plenty, the ONLY fan club Victorian based that acts like this at the MCG in my experience.

Collingwood are like choirboys next to Carlton fans.

Answer 20

Not the way i used to, back in '69, '72,'73, '82, they were Richmond/Carlton grand finals, it's died down now though, my mum was a Carlton fan, she's no longer alive, so for some strange reason i don't hate them like i used to.     In fact playing and being involved in footy for 38 years, knowing what players go through, commitment wise, i find it hard to hate any teams, BUT  Collingwood, now that's a whole different story, LOL,  smile your on candid camera.

Liesal Jones just won the Gold in 100m breaststroke,  that name always gets me going, BREASTstroke,  come on smile again, well don't then.

Answer 21

Well I don't hate them.  The main thing that has stuck in my mind about Carlton is that I heard all of the stories about the 1945 Grand Final Blood Bath where they beat South Melbourne and there were fights going on all over the place - on the ground and in the crowd too and the teams must have hated each other way back when.

Now I have seen them play some pretty good footy this year and the Swans were lucky to get out of that one where we only won by a couple of points.  But to cut a long story short they have some d**n good draft picks and I am a bit p.....off about that and getting advantages through tanking.  Plus John Elliott didn't endear me to Carlton either.  I do think they have the Best Theme Song in the AFL.

Watch out for them next year is my warning.  Oh I have always liked Fev and wouldn't have minded him at the Swans either.

Answer 22

NO NOT THIS LITTLE BLACK DUCK, and to sound like a ten year old .

...................................CAR... ARE THE BEST F#@K THE REST

personally i hate West Coke eagles they are the true meaning of arrogance.

Answer 23

Carlton arn't too bad, I don't mind them! I hate Collingwood more!  

Answer 24

I've never seen so many answers! Must have touched a nerve.

I strongly dislike Carlton supporters mainly. They buy a couple of champions from other clubs, cheat, so they can have first pick at the best young players, win a couple of games and there back to their arrogant selves. Never heard from them when they were loosing each week.

Answer 25

I am neither for or against carlton, though I cant stand fevola, hes over-rated

Answer 26

                                 Astrix

if you dare say you hate Carlton i will scream

i have liked Carlton since the day i was born

                                   from

                 Blue Boys Stevens Mine (fav)

Answer 27

well ye i hate them cos im a pies supporter and fev, tanking, and cheating

Answer 28

YES

lozz summed it up perfectly with her third dot point.

i hate the fact that carlton try and stay as close to the bottom as possible after losing the first few games of season...........

did essendon do that? no

last essendon spoon - 1933

they are also cheats and their supporters are the worse not collingwood

Answer 29

Hate, despise, detest, scorn, loathe, revile. These are all words I associate with Carlton.

They cheat and lie, they have criminals both as players and administrators. They have masturbators, murderers, corporate criminals, colluders, bankrupts, thiefs and then get all high and mighty at everyone else.

They have purchased their last 5 Flags and should be stripped of the last one for the obvious, blatant cheating of the salary cap.

Altogether, a lowly, untrustworthy, dishonest and downright scummy football club (and their supporters are worse).

I guess my answer is YES, I do hate Carlton!!

Answer 30

**I don't really care either way about Carlton, they're just another team and there are teams that I hate more than them.**

Answer 31

I could never hate the Blues. They're my team! They might frustrate the c**p out of me every now and then. But hey. Doesn't every team do that to it's supporters?

Top 4 in 2 years I reckon.