Do you like PATD better before "Pretty Odd" or now?

Question

I like them now, but i think i liked them better before "Pretty Odd".

I think the feeling of the songs feel different. "A Fever You Can't Sweat Out" doesn't feel or sound the same as "Pretty Odd".

I think "Pretty Odd" is a little too cheery.

Well what do you think?

And please if you don't listen to the band, then don't post rude comments.

Answer 1

I liked them before, and I like them now.  The albums certainly have different sounds, but I like them both, they are fun to listen to.

Answer 2

I liked them way better before Pretty Odd when they were Panic! At The Disco now they just sound all popish and they kind of sold out.

Answer 3

I think It's pretty odd that they are still in the music business, let alone ever started

Answer 4

Before

Answer 5

they were way better before my favorite was "i write sins not tradgedies" they just totally change theyre sound  

Answer 6

I really liked A Fever You Can't Sweat Out. At first I HATED Pretty.Odd

but I made myself like it. And now I kinda do. I LOVE Do You Know What I'm Seeing. LOL. Its retarded but its cool.

A statement by the band said something like "We've grown up and we hope that our fans have to" yeah right.

NEWS FLASH most of us haven't.  

Answer 7

DEFINITELY NOW

Answer 8

I liked them waaay better before. I hated Pretty Odd at first, but now it's kind of grown on me.. but still. I think they tried to hard to sound like music from the 70's. That's very good and all, but all their fans were enjoying their dancy pop-punk music...you can't just completely change genres. But oh well. THey're doing what they like. The fact that they're lyrics have become happier are nice though, I thought. I'm not into really depressing music. I also hated that they were trying to sound like the beatles.

Answer 9

i like them later

Answer 10

A liked A Fever You Can't Sweat Out for a little but then I grew out of it and now I pretty much hate it.

I think Pretty Odd is okay, it's better than the last one. But I still don't really like it.

I lost all respect for the band after they changed Panic! At The Disco to Panic At The Disco, honestly.

Answer 11

i liked both CDs equally...

Answer 12

I like them better now, after i heard pretty odd. Who likes anti cheery music anyway?

Answer 13

whats PATD? Is it a foreign police department?

Answer 14

Honestly.

I like AFYCSO better.

But, they were seventeen and eighteen when they made it.

And you can't expect a band to stay the same forever, think of it from their perspective.

I didn't like Pretty. Odd. the first time I listened to the songs, but it grew on me, I love it now =)

They are more mature therefore, their music is too =)

I love Panic ;D

Answer 15

i didnt like them before pretty odd, they were just a dumb emo band... pretty odd has some great tunes, and obviously influenced by the beatles...

and i like 'cheery' music!!! who wouldnt?