Do you support this kind of historical claims?

Question

The Zionists expelled the Palestinians out of Palestine in 1948 and in 1967 to create Israel .They claimed that Israel was in this place 3000 years ago.

Answer 1

No I don't. It's an illegal occupation

Answer 2

No, I do not "support" the "historical claim" that "the Zionists" expelled the Arabs in 1948 and 1967 since that is completely false.

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsou...

Answer 3

Whether or not Israel was in this place 3000 years ago it doesn't give them the right to expel the Palestinians out of Palestine.

"Israel" may have been in the place but so were a lot of other tribes and peoples.  Most of those peoples both Israelite and the many other peoples stuck around and are the ancestors of today's Palestinians who probably have more DNA  percentage-wise from those Israelites than Jews from Eastern Europe.  Too bad the Zionists, mostly from Eastern Europe, committed so many massacres in the name of Jews so no one wants to admit to that Israelite ancestry, even though its pretty mixed with the other peoples of that period and before and after.

Legally speaking, such ancient claims aren't recognized under international law either, and it certainly forbids the tactics used to expel the Palestinians such as mass murder and terror against innocent civilians.

Answer 4

Israel was there .

Long ago.

Before the young one was even born.

Most of the young one was only born after world war two.

Just the israeli coming back to their homeland.

With a purpose out there.

When they were lost with time.

While the Palestinian was there too.

With time.

With faulty education and communication system.

With misintrepretation, miscommunication, communication failures and communivation break-down.

They ended up in throwing pots and pans over a woman's error from her kitchen in bashing up one another in time.

Over the loss of their original identity.

In kicking the butts of God in not worshiping God with self lack of knowledge.

Luke 6.39-40,41-45,46-49

What do you think?

Answer 5

This kind of historical claim is bullshit for me. I live in Poland. There was the time when my country was very powerful and its borders reached from Baltic Sea to the Black Sea, maybe we should demand that we get back all this land, which today belongs to several other countries? Or maybe we should consider that there was no Poland 3.000 years ago and therefore it should not exist today?

It's all bullshit which has nothing to do with today's international law and international relations.

Answer 6

yeah but by same S***y token few hundred years ago USA was occupied by Indians, why not give them their country back and have all of us killed like palestinians.