Do you there is anything wrong with this man who loves his daughter so much that they had children together?

Question

Who are you to judge a persons love with one another?

http://edition.cnn.com/2008/WORLD/asiapcf/04/08/incest.aust/index.html

its not my cup of tea but can you really say this is wrong ? Its like saying homosexuality is wrong? very sad there being persecuted for love

Answer 1

I think it is a little odd. I mean how would you explain that to your kids when they get older? How do you explain that to the mother/wife? Im sure he does love her, but i dont think it is right. Yet I dont think they should be prosecuted for loving each other. I mean how would a relationship like that start in a home between a father and his child? I wouldnt be able to do it, but I dont think they should be prsecuted, its just there thing. lol

Answer 2

One simple answer: genetics.

Do you know what genetics is?  Can you say "genetics"?  Mister Rodgers probably could!

Answer 3

Sorry but it is illegal, immoral, and what are the children going to do when they grow up and learn their parentage, quite frankly i think it's abhorrent.

Answer 4

Oh gosh, well love knows no bounds I guess? but in this case and any other incest case I think love and make an exception and steer clear.

Answer 5

sick pervert comes to mind

Answer 6

wtf. its against the law for a very good reason, its wrong.

PS the first child died, incest babies are more prone to death and or medical defects another good reason this is wrong.

Its not the same as homosexuality, that I can understand. Yes their persecuted for this, and I can see why even if you can't, mind you that's your opinion and you're entitled to it.

Answer 7

they say incest is the best

jk lol

in my opinion i think it's wrong just because it's not fair to any offspring they may produce not just for the physical illnesses it might suffer but also it's mental well being i mean really how would that effect u if you found of your father was also grandfather and you mother was your sister\

and i think comparing this to homosexuality is like comparing bestiality to homosexuality, but i respect your opionion and you make a valid point

Answer 8

YES I can say it is wrong because it is illegal and apart from that, absolutely disgusting. All I can say is thank god their child was born healthily, however I feel so sorry for her for when she is older and finds out the truth about her 'parents' disgusting relationship.

That kid is going to be emotionally scarred for life and traumatised because of this.

What is the father going to do when he finds his new daughter (technically grandaughter) sexually attractive? Will he have it off with her as well?

I'm sorry if it sounds crass, but that is the exact nature of the situation. I'm disgusted and horrified by it and I can only hope that the poor child who had no say in the situation gets out of the freakshow family as soon as she can.

Answer 9

The father is a paedophile and should be burned on the village green.

Answer 10

There is a very good reason it is illegal--it dramatically increases the chance of physically and/or mentally defective children.  Their child appears to be normal, but it is early to judge her mental capacity.

Answer 11

Other than not having a brain he was just fine.

Answer 12

Its sick.

Answer 13

Well, when the kid is old enough to figure things out she will wonder why her father and grandfather are the same person, and also why her mother is also her sister...

Answer 14

dunno, not my cup of tea, and genetically its not good for kids, but who cares. i think it might be stranger for the guy thinkung its his offspring than for a woman who never met her dad before (could be like any other stranger.. er, if you go for old guys of course...)

Answer 15

Do I think it's wrong......?

Well, considering that incest is illegal, wouldn't that automatically make it "wrong" by definition?

I think the whole thing is creepy and sick.  The courts think it's "wrong", and it IS up to the courts to place judgement in this matter.

Answer 16

It's pretty obvious that genetically it is wrong.  Inbreeding amplifies genetic defects as this couple have found out.  

In our society it is also morally wrong, but not all societies are the same.   I remember reading about an African tribe who believed that the father had to take his daughter's virginity before her wedding.  The idea was that he taught her how to please her husband, but also that being her father, he would be loving and gentle with her for her first time.

While I can see the logic of that I'm afraid the thought of incest is completely alien to me.  But I think it is the genetic consequences that really  prove that incest should remain illegal.

Answer 17

not ok!!

there is something very wrong here!!!

Answer 18

It's wrong on every level.Against the law of the land,against the laws of nature.Puts the child in danger of psychological damage.Incestuous relationships are deemed wrong for a reason,not least that inbreeding can result in much greater incidences of hereditary illness in particular mental illness.you can't compare this with homosexual relationships as there would not be any children medically affected.Also incestuous relationships are pretty much totally shunned by society.

Answer 19

For a father to abuse a daughter in that manner is obscene. He should know better and be made to realise this. If she had only been 19, for instance, everyone would be repulsed but because she is a middle aged woman this is supposed to be acceptable?! If later on he gets his granddaughter pregnant is that acceptable?!

NO father should cross that line with his own progeny. Saying it bears any resemblance to homosexuality is ridiculous.

Answer 20

thats not for me how can anyone welcome this with open arms

Answer 21

Dude that's sick sh*t!!  So you are saying if your mother thought you were a stud muffin you'd be all over it?  Yikes!!