Do you think I would look better with or without eyeliner?

Question

I don't have any photos of myself without any eyeliner, but I have photos with little bit of eyeliner applied.

Photo 1,2,3: less eyeliner.

http://i247.photobucket.com/albums/gg158/bmth000/lalala-1.jpg

http://i247.photobucket.com/albums/gg158/bmth000/ocsah.jpg

http://i247.photobucket.com/albums/gg158/bmth000/yellow.jpg

Photo 4: Lots of eyeliner

http://i247.photobucket.com/albums/gg158/bmth000/bloddyjennier.jpg

Answer 1

Stick with less eyeliner but try doing a finer line on your upper eyelid.

I can't imagine you without, but I like your minimal eyeliner look.

Answer 2

Yeah, I'd stay away from eyeliner if I were you. You look loads better without it and more natural. I don't think its bad if you wear just a little bit but the photo with lots of eyeliner was way over the top.  

Answer 3

The 4th photo is photoshopped. =)

Less is so much better and doesn't make it racoon-ish.

Answer 4

You look pretty either way, but the less looks gorgeous to me. You would look like a total natural beauty without any at all!! You should save the heavy eye make-up for later.Hope I helped.:)

Answer 5

HMMMM well you look good with and without but dont put too much on or you will look cheasy

Answer 6

your idea of less...is alot

stick with that

alot of it, plus your black hair makes you look emo....

i put just as much as you do in your first 3 pix and i have black hair.

Answer 7

The less looks way better : )

Answer 8

I like it with less it gives you a natural look that won't make you look washed out!  

Answer 9

you look WAY better without it on.

i love the 3rd picture. :]

try using black eyeshadow for the outside of your eye instead of actual eyeliner.

it doesn't look as harsh.

i use eyeshadow instead and mine turns out like this:

http://i334.photobucket.com/albums/m418/...

Answer 10

less

Answer 11

Wear tons of it!!! I LAYER on the eyeliner! You are gerorgeous, woman! :]

Answer 12

without. looks really natural and beautiful. plus i dont know what the h**l was all over your face on the lots of eye liner one

Answer 13

YOU WILL LOOK BETTER W/ EYELINER

Answer 14

The less the better.

It's way too dramatic for day and way too dramatic for someone your age.

I recommend a smudgy pencil liner and big lashes as a substitute.

You're pretty enough without anything on!

Natural beauty is the best.  

Answer 15

the first pic you look really pretty...

Answer 16

Ok, I love pic #1, but less eyeliner is good for a natural look. It just depends on which look you're going for.

Hope this helps!

Answer 17

less eyeliner looks nice.. :]  

Answer 18

The less eyeliner makes you way prettier/beautiful & natural. xD