Do you think Maloney will be a good signing for Celtic if they sign him?

Question

I know what you mean about players returning but when they return theyr normaly old and past it, Maloney still has his best years ahead of him

Answer 1

would he even get a game now ?

Answer 2

Yes it would be good.

Answer 3

Well he did well for them first time around, they know what kind of player they are getting.  It is always hard when a player returns because the expectation levels are so high, but I am sure he would do well if he came back

Answer 4

as long as he brings the heart that he used to have for Celtic back with him then he will be a good re-signing.

May be tough getting him back though as you say they love him at Villa..you just have to check their forums etc to see that.

Where did the rumor go that he was seen at Murray Park.. everyone was convinced he was signing for Rangers?

Answer 5

is he any better than what the soap dodgers already have??? come on  you have that world beater paddy Mcourt and aids Mcgeady .......

cheerio to 4iar

Answer 6

52 in the bag ... nae feckin luck warmers

LMFAO......

Answer 7

never liked when players return he could still do a job but would rather we spent the money on someone else  

Answer 8

Why would you even want the wee hook nose jew back, like petrov, sutton, agathe, etc hes just another player thats failed in england.......and how many villa fans do you know ya gobbo ? What none.....thought so.

Answer 9

Possibly I didnae see him at the Beardmore Hotel the other night then. Still he has realised the grass isn't always greener etc. Only a few players return and make a success but it is possible, Baz for instance. His problem will be getting into the team, I cannot see him knocking any of the strikers out so as long as all players are fit, he will be a squad player only.

He must bide his time.

Answer 10

what exactly has he done at villa that has got all the teams fighting for his signature...of course he won't be a failure down south when its celtic that are signing him....rangers fans didn't want maloney cos we have alredy got better in our team

Answer 11

Yeah he would be a good signing but remember he is very much coming back a failure