Do you think Tim Smith is a great player in rugby league?

Question

Do you think he would be selected in the NSW state of origin team or do you think he should be dropped from the Parramatta 1st grade team?

Answer 1

Is Jarred Mullane a future legend??? Well according to the card i got in my packet of Salt and Vinegar chips... yes. But according to the real world... time will tell.

He has great potential... but as we've seen before.. that can be wasted away. He has the abilities to go far... but the attitude is what he needs to make it. Origin, i don't think the selectors will go for him... But Parra have a good thing if they can control him.

Answer 2

tim smith is good but not great .he won't get selected for nswcause hes a qlder{i think}. he just needs to settle down and get his head around what it means to be a pro nrl player. he has talent and ability to be a great player.

Answer 3

im a big parramatta supporter but im not very keen on tim smith. he does have talent but at times can be too predictable. ive come across him a couple times (at the pub of all places when he was supposedly on a booze ban) and noticed he has a terrible attitude. the halves of the team need to be positive leaders, did you see tim smith face everytime he dropped the ball last night, yes he was receiving bad passes but he always looked around for someone to blame. he should be in the side but is far away from origin, anyways looks whos in front of him, cronk, prince, thurston (hes a queenslander not nsw).

i hope andrew johns has a big influence on him this year and also think having finch outside him is a big help, he couldnt handle the side by himself.

Answer 4

every1 sed he was the nxt big thing after his rookie season, but then he became c**p

in my opinion, he is complete rubbish, dont know why the eels dont give finch the permanent halfback role

Answer 5

yeah he's a good player but there are better ones out there... so to speak..

Answer 6

He's good. He played good when he was dropped down to park footy.

They bring him back with big expectations. He drops the ball a couple of times and doesn't play too well.

Andrew Johns says he's trying to change and cut his drinking habits. Somehow I don't believe that, but I do believe that he'll get back to his great form.

At the moment I wouldn't even 'slightly' consider Tim to play for QLD (seeing as he's a Queenslander). Sorry Tim.

All the best this year.

Answer 7

he's a spoiled brat with his childish outbursts and should grow up.

Answer 8

No I don't, he had a good first year but hasn't shown much since. You can tell he has an attitude problem. I wouldn't want him in my side.

Answer 9

no he's a spastic good 4 the eels now dat brett finch is in

Answer 10

imo hes overrated...soo much hype about him, but he doesnt perform that well at all..

hes a queenslander too so hes got absolutely no dam chance of getting a spot, seeing as he has to go through thurston and prince plus other big players.

Answer 11

i think he would do better if he went to union