Do you think cheryl cole is a good judge on the x factor?

Question

Do you think cheryl cole is a good judge on the x factor?

Answer 1

I liked sharron a lot better. cheryl irritates me.

Answer 2

yes shes a good judge

shes gonna get better as the weeks go by aswell

shes been through it all before so knows how they feel

hope she gets the groups and wins overall

Answer 3

She's ok, she knows what its like to audition to be one of the contestants..........

                                but i still liked Sharon better :)

Answer 4

No, not really I think she is to nice but I think there is still more of her to see.

Answer 5

Yarp, she knows its exactly what the contestants are going through

and i thought on the first show she wasn't gonna be very talkative and a bit shy and nervous

but she was really good !

EDIT: I hated Sharon, she seemed really fake and was obviously gutted when Danii came on the show cos she wasn't the centre of attention anymore.

Answer 6

Well, it's early days but I don't think she tried to spot any potential she just chose those who were already good.

Personally I prefer Sharon.

Answer 7

No i dont she is a waste of time and cant sing!!!! so who is she to judge other people

Answer 8

although cheryl is very pretty, i do think Sharon was better judge, in the sense that she was more stricked and has more life experience.  

Answer 9

I gotta be honest she's a pretty ladie but she does not fit the character of a X factor judge, No i don't think she's good at it

Answer 10

I prefer Sharon To be honest.

Answer 11

Yh shes Ok  

Answer 12

No. Simon manages her so it's probably the only reason she's doing it. I don't want to see another orange wag on our TV screens.

I don't see how being pretty makes you a good talent judge, but she just looks like a chav to me anyway.