Do you think failing p.e. by not weighing 120pounds is fair or is that unfair?

Question

i mean i passed because i weighed 98 pounds but some of my friends didn't and they didn't even go on the scale the p.e. teacher just looked at them and said " your weight is 122, you need to loose 2 pounds"

Answer 1

Totally unfair! What if the kid weighed that much because he/she was tall, or very strong (muscle weighs more than fat). Report that teacher to the principal, or advise your friend to. I mean, "weighing" someone without using a scale is just plain mean.

Answer 2

That's unfair, you shouldn't be failing because of your weight, it should be on your effort in gym.  You should report him for that, why would he need your weight to be certain to pass?  That's just wrong.

Answer 3

Get your Q in the right section, this is cricket.

Answer 4

That sucks. It is unhealthy and contributes to a negative body image. Your PE instructor is a horse's rear and should be fired.

Answer 5

That is wrong.

You shouldn't fail P.E if you weight more than 120 lbs.

Tell your parents because teachers shouldn't say that

Answer 6

Dear Anne,

I agree with most others. It seems unfair.

Rehman of Multan

Answer 7

UNFAIR that is sick for some people that is unhealthy every one differs i mean if you were four feet and a few more inches and your friend was five feet then you would need to be different weights to be healthy that is really sick tell princable right away that is soooooooo UNFAIR