Do you think he would accept this trade?

Question

im giving: ronnie brown, chris cooley, dwayne bowe

getting: Clinton portis, LJ smith, and Jerry Porter...

i love Clinton and hes my favortie player... and i need a RB

Answer 1

If i was him im pretty sure i would'nt do it.  

Answer 2

He might. I really don't see how it makes either of you better. Except Ronnie Brown is going to be splitting carries with Ricky Williams. But by giving Bowe for Porter it almost evens it out.

Answer 3

I like what you have better.  

I think brown will be back to form, and starting every game by week4 or so....cooley is much better than LJ Smitha and bowe has much more upside than bowe.

Answer 4

yeh,its a good trade to me

Answer 5

Yes it is a stupid trade.  Don't pull the trigger.

If you want to watch the Skins and root for Portis then go for it. But if you want to be competitive in you fantasy league then of course not.  The person that offered you the trade obviously knows you are a skins fan.  That' why he offered you a WR & TE that have minimal value.  IMO Smith and Porter are waiver wire players.

If you want to be competitive in your league, don't give up Cooley or Bowe.  They are both valuable players considering their positions.  Each one has great upside.  Also, Ronnie Brown could work his way back as the potential starter for the Phins.  Worst case scenario, he splits carries.  Ricky Williams only played 6 games last year before he tore his pectoral muscle.

Don't make the trade.  It's bad from every angle.  You're already a Skins fan.  You don't need any more reason to cheer for them.

Only accept the trade if you are desperate @ RB and have more depth @ WR/TE.  Otherwise NO!

Answer 6

LOL...only if he plays Badmitten. Who would take that offer?

Answer 7

clinton portis is my favorite player too! do the trade. portis is a top 8 rb. johnson is an elite rb despite his o-line, and jerry porter has david garrard

Answer 8

Im going to say bad trade although portis is great the other two wont do **** this year and you will give up three solid starters for one good starter, you will lose depth on your team and that can hurt your playoff chances hope this helped

Answer 9

you're gonna have to give up more. While cooley looks to have a good season, brown is a question mark this year, and bowe has brodie croyle as a QB (besides he's the #2 target behind Tony Gonzalez)

Portis was probably a top 10 choice and you'll have to give up more to get him. Analyze what he needs and propose accordingly. if he needs a WR, you'll probably have to give up your #2 WR and #2 RB to make it worth it (and that's a 2 for 1 trade. though maybe you might be able to take one of his late round sleepers off him)

  

Answer 10

yeah pretty even but he might think Ricky Williams will take away carries from Ronnie Brown but I think they will get equal