Do you think that she is fat?

Question

I dont, and didnt think about it until someone gave me a rather rude answer sayign i should concentrate on the "fat over fed kid in your default pic"

She weighs 15 pounds, which according to her doctor is bang on target for her age...but this woman said she was fat and she looked disgusting.

So what do you think

Heres a slide show of recent pictures of her

http://s334.photobucket.com/albums/m430/CassieSmith123/Hallie1/?albumview=slideshow

She is my neice, and she lives with me almost permanantly except for one and a half days a week at most when her mam has her. So although she is not mine, i have the bond with her, and that womans comment really upset me...

She is 7 months old :)

Answer 1

i was u i would of reported her the min she did that. i think she is a little short that might be why she looks like it but other then that she is fine her legs are fine and every thing. my son is very tall at three months to four he was big as can be just one big thing but he was only 16 pounds and was that for like three months his doctor didnt say a thing. now he is almost 11 months old and is only 20 pounds and now they are saying he needs to gain two pounds. he is tall now. and is just fine he eats what ever i put in front of him. i think that women was wrong and should of been reported when she said that. man i got in troble for saying stuipd in a question. that should at least get her in to more for saying that. i think that it is great u are taking care of her. keep up the good work i bet that women would never take care of her neice like u do. good job and god bless u

Answer 2

d'awwwwwwwwh!!! shes soo cute!!kawaii!!!x/3

omg that person is sooo dead! SHE ISNT FAT,STUPID PERSON WHO SAID TAHT!!! (not you xD)

besides, most babies are pretty chubby, which makes them cuyoout! x]

Answer 3

she is so cute, when she grows up she will not be fat!

Answer 4

omg she is absolutely adorable... Some people are just so rude and are obviously just not happy so they try to bring others down. Thats what all babies look like and she looks perfect! don't let somebody like that bother you

Answer 5

oh don't let people bother you. that person is just a trouble maker, trying to bug you. certain members of my boyfriend's family used to tell us our daughter was too fat, that her doctor was wrong, and that we should put her on a diet. i wanted to punch them. you just have to ignore those idiots.

Answer 6

please. babies aren't fat. my girl is 25 lbs she is 9 months don't listen to anybody saying your kid is overweight exspecially if you actuall doctor for your child says they are not. that's so bad that someone would actually say that about a child

Answer 7

I think that she is gorgeous and she doesn't look too 'fat.' I used to get the opposite, everyone thought I wasn't feeding my son because he was always small for his age. He actually eats more then most other kids I know!

Answer 8

if you (an adult) is insecure about HER, how will you teach her to be confident, really. You shouldnt be that sensitive, or you will raise an insecure kid, you dont always have to please everyone and much less a stranger on the internet, who cares what she thinks!

she is just a baby, it is normal for babies to be chubby, i think she is perfectly fine and she is also a cutie :)

Answer 9

WHAT SHE IS NOT FAT

people must be blind if they say so

every baby is tht size but when they grow up they get in shape

Answer 10

shes just a chubby baby. Theres nuthin wrong with that. If every baby was as skinny as a toothpick, what on the baby would there be to love? shes beautiful and tell that lady to fUc* off!

Answer 11

people say mean c**p on here all the time, don;t take it personally.

And she looks fine. She has a chubby face, but it just makes her cuter!!

Answer 12

Babies are not fat. They use those chubby cheeks to fuel development. I agree with a pp, she's being a douche.

Answer 13

SHe has a cute chubby face, she's definitely not fat.

Answer 14

SHE IS PRETTY AND JUST RIGHT....BETTY.

Answer 15

Wow..you have got yourself a cutie pie!!  She is totally NOT fat and people that think so are just crazy!!  Don't worry about what other people like that say.  It's rude!!!

Answer 16

I just reported J. Judy's response to your first question on the ear piercing - that is rude -

Your niece is not fat at all. Chubby is a word I would use, but it is not a bad thing, more a cutsie term. Her body weight, size, shape will be up and down for a long time. As long as the doctors say she is healthy, that is what matters. My son has always been "above average" in size, but he is totally healthy and gets plenty of physical activity. Don;t start worrying about the weight until the doctors do. Take care!

Answer 17

she is totally adorable

your doc is right she is not fat...my son has always been on the high side of the curve and if I calculate his BMI he is fat but when you look at him he isn't he is well built and I can never expect him to be skinny either his father and uncles are well built men...and the doctor never mentioned about his weight....

I just make sure what he eats is healthy and he eats a lot of fruit and veggies...so just make sure she eats healthy and everything will be ok...

she is just too cute and that lady was jealous

Answer 18

I think chubby babies are healthy babies!  My niece was breast fed for a year and weighed a  28lbs at a year old.  Now she is 5 and super scrawny but really really tall. Once they are more mobile and start to get height they lean out.  

Don't listen to what these people say!

Answer 19

She looks so freakin  cute!!!!! and i really dont think shes over weight she looks so perfect and cute and cute!

Answer 20

That woman is rude, heartless, disgusting and probably aborted all her kids. Dont feel bad, I brag when my baby puts on weight. That is just baby fat. she will lose it as she grows. Feed her healthy foods and you shouldn't have to worry. My daughter is two months old and weighs 12 pounds. I am one very proud mom. Negative people usually have nothing going for them. I dont think she is fat!!! she is well fed and healthy.

Answer 21

That person was just being a douche. Nothing wrong with your niece. She's cute as h**l!

Answer 22

no she is not fat she is lovely what does worry me is that i have just looked at all those photo's and she is naked in the bath there are nasty people out there who love seeing kids i would take those photo's off so no one can see them apart from yourself

Answer 23

thax a cute lil baby.......personally i hate skinny babys...everyone love a chubby baby.....dont mind tha otha people shes not fat she beatiful

Answer 24

What a beautiful kid!  What a sweet smile! She's not fat at all.  All babies look like that, thought not always so cute.

Answer 25

At fifteen pounds I think she is fine.  My son was a husky baby and people would joke about how he almost weighed as much as I do.  I would always take it with a grain of salt because at that age it is far better to have a husky baby than a skinny baby.  Think about it this way, what if she were to become ill.  A scrawny baby may not have the reserves needed to fight an illness or sustain from becoming emmaciated.  Once my son started to walk he slimmed down immediately, as will your neice I'm sure.  He still has his cute chubby cheeks though.  Don't let that woman bother you.  Also remember that there is a difference in generations.  There was a time when people believed babies should be skin and bones and women should only gain 5-10 lbs during pregnancy.  Thank God those days are gone!

Answer 26

she's adorable!  well, it's not like you can put a baby on a diet..my nephew is 10 lbs at 5 weeks old!  he was born at 8 lbs.

she's fine, you don't need to worry about "child obesety" until she hits like 5 or 6.

Answer 27

omg she is a cutie!! thats just baby fat she will grow out of it alot of babys have it. don't worry she is not fat she 's perfect!!

Answer 28

tell people like that to shove it. She is perfect and adorable, Beautiful eyes by the way!!

Answer 29

OMG no way that ladys horrible! she's so adorable I looked at like every pic i love the  "I'm in a pan" one and wher she was sleeping with her milk. She was cubby too with the little chubby face and legs. I love babys like that and its normal and only adds to their cute factor like 10 more points!! Not that she needs it! Dont worry that lady was probably just jealous!

Hope I helped :)

Answer 30

omg shame on that women!   shes verry cute my son is 6 months old and he weighs 17 pounds  but he is 2 in taller then he should be,   i think he will be atleast 6'1   that lady  is crazy,

Answer 31

Shes ok and my nephew is 7 months and he weights 25 pounds so jus keep feeding her