Do you think the Yankees are kepping Nady and Pudge after this season?

Question

Do you think the Yankees are kepping Nady and Pudge after this season?

Answer 1

I think they'll let Abreu go and keep the much younger Nady.

Pudge will go -- who needs TWO mid-30 yr old catchers

Answer 2

They probably will keep Nady and let Damon go. I highly doubt they'd bring Pudge back because of Posada.

Answer 3

Pudge: Definitely not. Posada will come back healthy and it's his job once he does. No sense in keeping two aging all-star caliber catchers.

Nady: Depends. If they can trade Damon or Melky Cabrera or if they let Bobby Abreu walk, he's sure to be kept.  

Answer 4

Nady is signed through 2009, so he is a yes. As far as Pudge, he is now 38 years old and if Posada can prove he is healthy, they will sign Jorge instead.

Answer 5

Pudge Yes, if Posada can not make it back in time. Nady no!

Answer 6

If NY doesn't sign Abreu, then they'll sign Nady. Ans as for Pudge, I dout he'll stay in NY with Posada there, unless NY doesn't re sign Giambi and then Posada can split time with Pudge at 1B/C

Answer 7

yes on both. but i dont think either will be starters. they already have an amazing power hittin outfield and posada will definatley be the startin catcher so the question is molina or pudge