Do you think these names are too plain?

Question

Elsie, Rose and Claire. If you met three sisters with those names would you think they were a beautiful combination, unusual or boring/plain?

Answer 1

i love the name claire as it is my name, also love rose but not that keen on elsie its quite odd!

Answer 2

How about Agnes, Rose and Clara? Similar sounding names but a little more dainty and beautiful.

Answer 3

The only one I like is Elsie but with the combination of Rose and Claire makes them sound dull xD

Answer 4

Well I have to say that I like the name Claire as it is my name!  Not sure about Elsie but I love Rose.  I also like Rosemary but I prefer it spelled Rosemarie (not sure why!).  How about Eloise instead of Elsie?   It's quite similar but not quite as old-fashioned.

Answer 5

Isabelle, Rose and Isla sound better but they are all very nice

Answer 6

Isabelle is nice, but not Elsie, Rose is a really pretty name.  My friend is called Rose and it really suits her.

Answer 7

I'm not a fan of the name Claire but they others are okay

Answer 8

Nice names, though Elsie is wildly old-fashioned (just coming back?).

ISLA is a horrible name, please don't go for it unless you come from the Outer Hebrides.

Answer 9

i would change elsie to elena or elenor...or better yet... elizabeth.

and rose is ok.... but kinda boring... so katherine? maggie?

and claire is nice.  

Answer 10

I like Isabelle.

Hate rose-old ladyish.

Indigo sounds boyish

Isla is ugly.

Answer 11

I love Elsie and Rose. But I am not keen on Claire. Have you considered Clarissa?

xX

Answer 12

Claire's a bit rubbish - i know lits of people called claire. I like the other two, Elsie's really cute.

Answer 13

I like those names.  I would think they were just a beautiful combination.

Answer 14

Love love Rose on it's own. In fact I prefer just Rose, not sort for anyhing. It's absolutely gorgeous, and not at all plain.

Isla is lovely as well.

Isla, Rose, and Claire would be a stunningly set of names for sisters.

Great choices.

I don't like the middle name Indigo though. Yuck.

Answer 15

Very old fashioned, to the point of sounding ridiculous, especially Elsie !!!!  

Whenever I hear it I think of the full name, Elspeth, which is hideous!

Please don't do that to your kids.

P.S. My mum's name is Rosemary but no-one ever calls her Rose, because it's such a granny name!  Rosie is her usual moniker and it sounds much cuter than Rose.

EDIT: MOVIE GEEK 91, you are my double!!!

Answer 16

Elsie is my fave, but Claire is my least fave. A bit plain.

Answer 17

i like them, elsie i like the least because i know someone that named her cow that sorry.  i like ella or elle instead

Answer 18

i think that they are beautiful!!!!!

Answer 19

The names are okay but these days  kids named Isabelle are called Izzy I don't know why but every kid I know named isabelle is called Izzy . I like Rose but how about Rose Marie or Anna Rose.  Indigo I know I person named Indigo and everybody calls her Indy even at work the managment calls her Indy.  So it doesn't really matter what  the names are somebody somewhere will start a nickname and it will stick

Answer 20

I think that they are a nice combination, but don't use Indigo for a middle name it sounds ridiculous. And substitute Claire for Isla.

Answer 21

I don't like Claire it does sound boring,

I like Isabelle & Rose,

Answer 22

I know a few Rose's none I would say are boring or plain

Pick a name you love, and go with that

I have met one Claire, did not like her, but that's okay, she was very pretty

I never met an Elsie, but I do not think of the name as plan or boring

Answer 23

I think Elsie is a horrible name but the other two are fine.

Answer 24

No, I like them.

Answer 25

Love the name Isabelle - one of my favourites!!

Answer 26

I like Rose a lot

Answer 27

i dont like rose, that shud be just like a middle name

Answer 28

beautiful

Answer 29

They sound quite old-fashioned and traditional, but pretty all the same :)

Answer 30

rosemary is an old lady name. dont like the name claire. elsie is alright

Answer 31

they are a lovely combination i really love elsie and rose (!!) not too sure on claire though....its quite dull and i can only think of slightly dull claires that i've met...