Do you think this trade could be accepted?

Question

I get clinton portis for the washington redskins. And i give up Larry Johnson and Lindale White.

Answer 1

That trade is horrible. Clinton Portis is a hangnail away from missing the season. LJ and LenDale may have good seasons this year. Don't do it!

Answer 2

I am not a big White fan because the Titans have drafted so many RBs high in the draft lately.  However, he did rush for 1K yards last year.  

I consider Portis and LJ on the same level.  Both have some issues.  

I wouldn't do the trade because White could surprise people and be a good #2 RB.  You are giving up some potential for gaining very little..if any.

Answer 3

This trade is a high stakes gamble.

Portis is a Machine but that is exactly the problem.

If he goes down so will your team.

Stay with what you have and pick up Mendenhall of the Steelers or Felix Jones of Dallas as backup. Even TJ Duckett will score loads of TD's for Seattle as Julius Jones does the runnin.

Stay put on this one!

Answer 4

I like that trade

Answer 5

I think that's a fair trade.  There are some who will say LJ is better than Portis, but I think Portis is a little better.  About one Lendale White better.  I wouldn't make the trade if I were you, but it's not crazy.

Answer 6

Yes.

Answer 7

The guy will definitely accept it because Larry Johnson is first round material and White can get 100 yd games