Does Tom Brady really deserve to be mentioned alongside Roger Federer and Tiger Woods?

Question

A few days ago I read an article comparing Brady to Golf legend Tiger Woods and tennis legend Roger Federer.

I commend Brady for an excellent season, but last night he choked when history was on the line. Also he is not a naturally talented quarter back. He wasn't even first choice in college. He would be nothing without a great offensive line. His only standout quality was that he is clutch, but last night when history and immortality was on the line he most certainly was not clutch. The moment was too big for him. Woods and Federer were prodigies in their respective sports. They are regarded as the most naturally talented in the history of their sports. Brady isn't even the most naturally talented quarter back today.

When you ask people who is the greatest Quarter back of all time, a most people would not say Brady. If you ask people who is the greatest Golfer and greatest tennis player, a large percentage of people would say Tiger Woods and Roger Federer

Answer 1

It is impossible to compare Tom Brady to either Tiger woods or Roger Federer.Tiger and Roger play individual sports.They do not have teammates helping to achieve their goals.Tom Brady is a great quarterback but his success is still very dependant on the quality of players he is surrounded by.It was evident in the Superbowl that without his offensive line giving him time in the pocket he was a mere mortal.In a team sport like football even the greatest players of their time cannot win without a very good supporting cast around them.

Answer 2

no GIANTS RULE~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Answer 3

Well Brady has won a few Superbowls just like Tiger has won many tour events as has Federer. But Tiger has chocked before as has Federer. It's all relative.

Answer 4

no

Answer 5

A lot of people like to compare athletes among different sports. My personal opinion is that we should athletes only in their individual sport.