Does anyone else this Fedor Emelienko is overrated?

Question

I mean hes undefeated and all, but to me he looks beatable.. now after seeing anderson silva at 205 today, he doesnt! .. he looks like he mite just get a shot at the light heavy real quik

Answer 1

Silva cannot beat Fedor!  It's unreasonable to think that a fighter who fights best at 185 will just jump up to 230ish pounds and be as strong, agile, or fast.  It's no different than if you were to claim that Silva looks unbeatable so Fedor should jump down 40 some pounds and fight Silva.  Not going to happen.

Answer 2

I was one of the guys who thought he was over-rated.

But I have to say I was impressed by his win Saturday over Sylvia.

I still don't think he is the best overall, but he is the best heavyweight.

James