Does end of anubis negat treeborn frog?

Question

thinking of putting the end of anubis in my deck ... but i generally need to use treeborn .. i dont know the ruling for this and cant find it anywhere ... what do you think?

Answer 1

yes i dose since you have to send treeborn to grave yard to activate its effect

Answer 2

the end of anubis has something else that necrovalley doesn't have. necrovalley says to negate card effects that target the graveyard. so effects like from the magician of faith or monster reborn won't work. but treeborn frog's effect doesn't target the graveyard; it activates in the graveyard.

end of anubis will negate treeborn frog's effect. it also says that card effects that target a card in the graveyard are negated. but it also says "...that activate in the Graveyard are negated." necrovalley doesn't have that in its text, which is why treeborn frog can still be summoned even with necrovalley on the field. but it can't be summoned if end of anubis is on the field because anubis's effect negates effects that activate in the graveyard

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/The_End_of_...

http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Necrovalley

Answer 3

Im pretty sure it negates everything that has to do with the grave and treeborn frog is no exception. If u want grave disruption I suggest running one of the new gravekeeper variants. If u wanna c 1 in action visit a metagame feature match.

Answer 4

yes, end negates treeborn, "someone" already put up the specifics to this ruling, but i'm just giving extra support what with being a judge and all, treeborn is a non-targetting effect