Does my Makeup look better now?

Question

Awhile ago i asked people here how old i looked and alot of people commented that my eyeliner was WAY to dark so i tryed my best to use as little as i could and this is how it looks now:

http://es.tinypic.com/view.php?pic=vxozz7&s=4

And this is how i looked before:

http://es.tinypic.com/view.php?pic=207qka9&s=4

Answer 1

Looks good. I like the shadow too!

Answer 2

i liked your make up how you did it before

Answer 3

tons better. =)

i'm sure ppl are still gonna tell you that it looks a bit harsh- but thats just cuz its black. but i am not hating on you hun- i have an addiction to blackest black eyeliner too. brown just looks funny. lol.

Answer 4

yeah much better,

you have gergeouss eyes you shouldnt hide them behind thick eyeliner

Answer 5

you looks great both ways but i like the new look.

Answer 6

I guess now you know more is not always better.

Answer 7

its pretty

Answer 8

no.

i like how it looked before.

i love eyeliner.

the second pic was hott.

u should do ur make up how u like it not how others think u should do it :)

Answer 9

Definitely looks better now. Looks cleaner, more natural, just gorgeous.

Answer 10

its much better now.. it looks good

Answer 11

woww, so much better! your beautiful eyes aren't hiding behind all that black dark makeup! good choice!

Answer 12

well i think it looks really nice now not that it looked badd b4 its just that looks really punk not my style

Answer 13

it looked more edgy befor but it looks cleaner now btw your hair rox and youre pretty you look 17

Answer 14

From your last one it is a HUGE improvement but i'd have to say it is still a bit dark for my liking. Did you know you could be perceived as "goth" or labelled as "emo". I think just a little fine line on black on the bottom lash, in the very right hand corners would look nice. Maybe even a little bit of white on the insides. Try and keep it au naturale :)

Answer 15

A little heavy on the eyeliner there.

Answer 16

your make up look alot nicer BEFORE

yr welcome

Answer 17

uhm, i liked your picture before.

it reminds me of amber tamblyn :)

love her!  

Answer 18

Your makeup looks better now. 8)

Answer 19

don't worry about them they know nothing do what u like your gorgeous no madder what to me i like the punk look but that's just me but u look so good with both  

Answer 20

YOU'RE STILL UGLY AS HECK.

Answer 21

yeah it looks nicer....i know you didn't ask about your eyebrows....but they're kinda bad.  

Answer 22

It looks good. I love wearing eyeliner, it's a great way to highlight the eyes.

Answer 23

your makeup looks a lot better now.