Does she sing well enough for lessons?

Question

this is my younger sister, Nikki and i was just wondering what you think of her singing.

She has been through a lot lately and one thing she really loves is to sing and so i was thinking of getting her some singing classes if its worth it.

what do you think?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLTwy9PV6BA&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CGnWBA5q-Co

Answer 1

She's really good but her voice doesnt sound mature enough so maybe she would benefit from singing lessons.

Answer 2

Judging from the first song she is hopeless. Better on the second song.

Lessons can never hurt, but dont get her hopes up.

Answer 3

Every kid can benefit from singing lessons.  If nothing else, they teach proper breathing skills for singing and good vocal technique.  They can also boost confidence for kids.  You have nothing to lose.  Just look for a qualified teacher!

Answer 4

I couldn't listen to the singing because the sound mode isn't working on my computer but I just want to say she is really pretty. Goodluck. x

Answer 5

singing lessons are for everyone. They will teach her all she needs to know so I say go for it

Answer 6

very good

Answer 7

She is very good and a very pretty talented young girl! I personally would get her lessons!

Answer 8

why don't you pay for a lesson or two and get the honest opinion from a professional teacher.After all this isn't American idol  

Answer 9

being honest, she has potential, I say if it's something she wants, pay for the lessons, like everyone else is saying she will only benefit from it and I'm sure with professional help she will be much better. I am not saying she is bad or as someone above me said "hopeless" the talent is there, she just needs a boost and to be taught correct techniques and notation.

midnight writer