Does this trade sound fair?

Question

I Trade volquez and rollins for halliday and guzman

Answer 1

I dont think that was a good idea. It's not a fair trade and if you are the guy who has Volquez and Rollins it's a bad idea. Don't do it if u haven't already.

Answer 2

I wouldn't do it. Guzman isn't near as good as Rollins, because Guzman doesn't have as much power or speed. Halladay is more consistent than Volquez, but all in all, he's not as good.

Answer 3

No way! Volquez and Rollins are still young players, while Guzman and Halladay are getting up there in age. Plus, Volquez > Halladay and Rollins > Guzman.