Eddie Bravo vs. BJ Penn?

Question

In an MMA match

and

In a grappling match

and who do you think would win?

Answer 1

BJ Penn would win in both. BJ Penn trained in BJJ for 3.5 years, got his black belt and became one of two americans to win the worlds. Eddie Bravo beat Royler Gracie but never won any competitions at black belt.

Answer 2

BJ in both Eddie Bravos just riding on beating Royler Gracie one time