Eric Cantona or Roy Keane, who had the most profound effect for Manchester United ?

Question

Eric Cantona or Roy Keane, who had the most profound effect for Manchester United ?

Answer 1

It's got to be Cantona. See I'm a Liverpool fan but I can ever forget the way Cantona plays.

Answer 2

I think Eric Cantona was better, by far to be honest but Roy Keane was gravy in his time too

Answer 3

Cantona. Everyone will ALWAYS remember him and he is still considered as one of the best players Man U had. Only pity is he didnt win the CL with Man U. But still my vote goes on him.

Answer 4

yes cantona i say

Answer 5

i loved the way roy keane played the game,but cantona gets my vote

Answer 6

Cantona scored more goals and had more skills but keane was a natural leader and put his heart and body on the line for the club, sorta like Vinnie Jones

Answer 7

7.ERIC CANTONA SIR DAVE

Answer 8

L'enfant Terrible of course.

Answer 9

Teams hated to play against man u because of roy keane but then because of cantona aswell just in a different light cantona gets my vote.

Answer 10

Eric the king was the missing link in the team, as the season before we lost the title to Leeds so his signing was key in bringing the title to OT. The rest as they say is history

Answer 11

Cantona, It was the signing of Cantona that lifted the whole club the first year United won the Premier League because it wasn't a great start to the season, but Eric came in and his goals and assists where vital for United, he was probably the last piece of the jigsaw to coin a phrase, Just Eric's presence on the pitch seemed to give United a air of invincibility, even though Keane was a world class player, IMO Cantona will always be viewed as more of a legend than him.

Answer 12

good question.

roy keane while cantona had tons of ability and is one of the biggest presences at Old Trafford ever Roy Keane was always there when relied upon and he had for two or three seasons the whole team relying on him. He arrived for a british record fee(3.75m alot at the time) and within two months the fans idolised him. Roy's never to give up attitude represents everything Manchester United stands for.And while Eric was unbelievable in domestic competitions he was never mentally good enough to play the football against top teams like madrid and juve. I'm sure we all remember Roy's whole-hearted display against juve in the 1999 champ league semi when he knew he would miss the final. This demonstrates his commitment to the club and remember winning the 99 treble was what put United on top of European clubs of the last 12 years.

Answer 13

cantona we had the chance to sign him and stupid souness didnt

Answer 14

cantona.. he taught the kids how to believe in there own ability...

Answer 15

Cantona