Eu SUPERPOWER!?

Question

Why doesnt the EU federalize?? it is in everybody's interest.

According to the World Bank, a united EU would have:

GDP (PPP) $m 13,881,051,000 each year.

compared to america's 13,020,861,000

..but which would the EU's universal language be?

Answer 1

Because the EU is only a diplomatic and economic deal, each state still has its own sovreignty, it wouldnt make sense for them to become one, theres too much tradition , history, and cultural differences for it to be viable

Answer 2

Anyone remember the Soviet Union, and that turned out well. If i was a modern day dictator how would i take over europe, how would i do it? Well hitler, napolean and countless others tried force, and it didnt work - but the most devastating form of modern day weapons is beauracracy.

We didnt win the second world war, we just put off our defeat for 60 years.

We were told by our own government (who were told by the EU) that england would not simply become a state of the USE but it has all the hallmarks of a modern day soviet union.

Answer 3

yes i agree with Karen, we don't need the EU, its just another club for the politicians. and more jobs for bureaucrats, still they have done a good job brainwashing some of the weaker minded among us haven't they, no wonder we are in deep ****.

Answer 4

To be ruled by the French and Germans........no thanks,its bad enough now.

We do not want to be in the EU, we do not need to be in the EU and we should get out of the EU.END OF!

Answer 5

Because federalizing leads to socialism and failure. That's what has happened to America and is why we are failing.

Answer 6

EU is not a one country concept.It is only a Union of many countries ,each retaining its individual stautus.They only follow a common economic policies.There is no common language suggested.EU is viable as Euro proved to be strong international currency competing with US $.The success of EU depends on integration of economies of member nations and following common agreed economic policies.

Answer 7

EU has the potential to be a great group to reckon with if able to constitute as one federal entity.  However, the problem will be on the people who wanted to be distinct as different countries.

Answer 8

You are right. In future when the world is divided into superstates and there are super billionaires everywhere, one guy like Abramovich would buy up little old England and turn it into a golf course. Enjoy!

Answer 9

The EU functions a bit like colonial America did before the colonies ratified the Articles of Confederation, in many respects.

As you point out, Economically the EU functions as a bloc and therefore is an economic superpower just slightly larger than than United States in overall GDP.

Politically it can and has acted in "grand concert" where the various national ministers agree on a course of action, however this is rare and it is much more often that

consensus cannot be reached and there is effective paralysis.

The EU has a parliament, but this is largely toothless when compared to the US Congress or Senate , the Bundestag or Landtag of Germany or the Peoples Assembly in China however it's relative power is increasing.

Militarily, the EU has only recently started to coordinate and function as a unit , mostly is as an adjuct to and as an artifact of the NATO alliance, which includes American forces.

Based on previous historical confederations, by about 2050 or so one might expect that the EU would function more like a modern variant the early US government in most respects.

See the CIA page on the EU and US

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications...

I also recommend the excellent "Rise and Fall of the Great Powers".

As far as a common languages, that is an EXCELLENT reason this movement towards supra federal government has not moved along as easily as it might have otherwise.

I suspect that a Unified European States will eventually have several "official" languages, German, English, French, Spanish etc.

Answer 10

Why would a united states of Europe be in anyone's interest?  We would have no control over our individual economy or legislature! Big is not best, and Britain in not part of Europe! You say 'superpower' as if it were automatically a good and desirable thing!

Answer 11

The EU is trying to do just that.  Although all it will do is create a SUPER rich people and very poor.  But I guess that doesn't really matter to many people because we are nothing more than serfs to the rich.

Answer 12

Noone apart from Germany and France want a federal superstate! When will they realise that!

We stopped them making one 60 years ago, and now they are slowly creeping it in through the back door!!!

A soveriegn power such as ours will lose a h**l of a lot more than it gains in a superstate.

Answer 13

WE got da power!

Answer 14

World Bank figures are outdated. The EU GDP for 2007 will be $15.7 trillion.   We do not need a political federation in the EU to better the USA economy, or for any other reason.  Indeed the political compromises generated by 27 diverse nations is more likely to detract from economic growth and wealth.

Answer 15

the eu can sod off!!!.

Answer 16

The EU is Federalized.  Sort of.

Each country in the EU is a sovereign nation and I believe each follows a federalized model of government.  The EU is not a country, it is a unique alliance between a plethora of soverign states and looking (or not depending) to take on more members.  Like all alliances everything is done by treaty.  The EU parliament is set up by treaty.

Each state actor (country) retains it sovereignty.  While it has agreed to partake of an economic treaty that has several other aspect this does not detract from the fact that each is still a sovereign nation.  Each is still responsible for its own defenses.  With all of that I find it difficult to believe that the GDP will change all that much as the EU has a GDP already and federalizing won't change that.

So why don't they federalize?  They're sovereign nations with their own laws and cultures and histories, including over a thousand years worth of waring with each other.  The governments don't want to federalize the EU ane it seems that the people, the citizens, in the EU don't want that either.  That is enough in democracies.

As to what language would be the official EU language?  Pluralize that and you have your answer. What languages would be the official languages?  The same ones they are now.