FANTASY FOOTBALL: Fair Trade?? P. Manning for Willie Parker and Mark Bulger?

Question

Fair? If not who is getting the better deal?

Answer 1

not fair at all manning is way to good for parker and bulger

Answer 2

Definitely get Peyton. Marc Bulger is so bad you can't even spell his name right.

Answer 3

I would never trade manning for those 2 guys. Parker is coming off an injury and so bulgers always hurt. Manning is an elite fantasy player, neither of these guys are. If that team needs a RB they should add one through free agency.  

Answer 4

if u get manning and trade parker and bulger do it

Answer 5

While Manning is good without a doubt I wouldn't go so far as to say "do not get rid of Manning". While he most likely have a better year than Bulger I wouldn't say the trade is unfair. The trade is fairly even in that Bulger will put up comparable numbers and then you get the points from Parker as well. That Being said I would keep Manning for the simple fact that there is so much out there in the running back department that you can very easily get someone who will put up the same type numbers as Parker, and quite a few who will put up better numbers. I bet there is at least 3 on th waiver wire that will have a better year than Parker. Believe it or not I would say Kevin Jones of the Bears will do as well or better.

Answer 6

I think its fair, especially if that person needs a RB.

Willie Parker has had over 1200 rushing yards the past 3 years.  I'd rather have an elite QB like Manning, but the trade seems fine to me.

Answer 7

If you're the one trading Manning away, you should get a higher caliber back than Parker.

Is the team with Manning (needing an RB) heavy on QBs? If you're set at QB even with trading Manning away, look for a top tier RB or 2 second tier RBs.